Table of Content

God Sees The Truth But Waits Exercise Solution - Question Answers [ Class 11 ]

Class 11 English (NEB) · Unit 1: Short Stories · Chapter 3
God Sees the Truth, but Waits
by Leo Tolstoy

In this post, you will find complete notes on God Sees the Truth, but Waits by Leo Tolstoy from the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook: the author's introduction, a detailed summary, character sketches, themes and symbols, and answers to all the textbook questions, along with additional important questions for exam preparation.

About the Author

Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) was a Russian writer and one of the greatest masters of realistic fiction. Born into a wealthy aristocratic family, he lost both parents as a child and was raised by relatives. He studied languages and law at Kazan University but left without a degree and educated himself on his family estate. He later served as an army officer and wrote Sevastopol Sketches (1855) from his experience of the Crimean War.

His first novel, Childhood (1852), was followed by Boyhood (1854) and Youth (1857), completing an autobiographical trilogy. He is best known for the great novels War and Peace (1869) and Anna Karenina (1877), and for novellas such as The Death of Ivan Ilyich (1886) and Hadji Murad (1912). In the last three decades of his life, Tolstoy became world-famous as a moral and religious teacher who preached simple living, love, forgiveness and non-violence.

Introduction to the Story

"God Sees the Truth, but Waits" was first published in 1872. It tells the story of Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov, a merchant who is falsely convicted of murder and spends twenty-six years in a Siberian prison. The story is a parable of forgiveness: it shows that human justice can fail, but God knows the truth, and that true peace comes through faith and forgiving one's enemies rather than through revenge.

Summary

Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov is a young merchant of the town of Vladimir who owns two shops and a house. He is handsome, fair-haired, curly-headed, full of fun and fond of singing. As a young man he drank and became riotous when drunk, but after marriage he gave up drinking except now and then.

One summer, as he sets off for the Nizhny Fair, his wife begs him not to go that day, because she has dreamt that he came back with his hair quite grey. Aksionov laughs it off as a lucky sign and leaves. Halfway, he meets a merchant he knows, and they spend the night at the same inn in adjoining rooms. Aksionov rises before dawn, pays his bill and continues his journey.

About twenty-five miles on, while he rests at another inn playing his guitar, a police officer arrives with two soldiers and questions him. The merchant he stayed with has been found with his throat cut. When they search his luggage, they find a blood-stained knife in his bag. Frightened, Aksionov can only stammer that it is not his. His pale face and trembling make him look guilty. He is bound, thrown into a cart and imprisoned, charged with murdering a merchant from Ryazan and robbing him of twenty thousand rubles.

His wife visits him in prison with their small children and tells him that her petition to the Czar has been rejected. Then she asks, "Was it not you who did it?" Heartbroken that even his wife suspects him, Aksionov says, "It seems that only God can know the truth; it is to Him alone we must appeal, and from Him alone expect mercy." He stops writing petitions and only prays. He is flogged and sent to the mines in Siberia.

For twenty-six years he lives as a convict. His hair turns white as snow; he stoops, walks slowly, speaks little and never laughs, but he often prays. He learns to make boots, buys The Lives of the Saints and sings in the prison choir. The authorities like him for his meekness, and the prisoners respect him, calling him "Grandfather" and "The Saint", and ask him to settle their quarrels.

One day a new convict arrives: Makar Semyonich, a tall, strong man of sixty from Vladimir. From his words and his surprise on learning Aksionov's story ("How could anyone put a knife into your bag while it was under your head?"), Aksionov becomes sure that Makar is the real murderer. That night, memories of his wife, his children and his lost youth fill him with misery; he is so wretched that he is ready to kill himself, and he longs for revenge.

A fortnight later, Aksionov discovers that Makar is digging a tunnel under the prison wall. Makar threatens to kill him if he tells. When the tunnel is found, the Governor asks Aksionov, known to be truthful, who dug it. Aksionov struggles with himself but finally says, "I cannot say, your honour. It is not God's will that I should tell!"

That night Makar comes to him, kneels and confesses that he killed the merchant and hid the knife in Aksionov's bag. He begs for forgiveness, sobbing that Aksionov's pity is harder to bear than flogging. Aksionov weeps too and says, "God will forgive you! Maybe I am a hundred times worse than you." At once his heart grows light and his longing for home leaves him. Makar confesses his crime to the authorities, but when the order for Aksionov's release comes, he is already dead.

Main Characters

Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov

Aksionov is the protagonist. As a young man he is cheerful, handsome, fun-loving and fond of singing, with a weakness for drink that he gives up after marriage. Falsely convicted, he suffers terribly but turns to faith in God. In prison he becomes meek, patient, honest and deeply religious, respected as "The Saint". Though tempted by anger and revenge when he meets the real murderer, he rises above them, refuses to betray Makar and forgives him. He represents the triumph of faith, patience and forgiveness over hatred.

Makar Semyonich

Makar is the real murderer: a tall, strong man of sixty, cunning, boastful and a habitual criminal. He lets an innocent man suffer for twenty-six years and even threatens to kill him. Yet Aksionov's mercy touches his conscience. He repents, confesses and begs forgiveness, showing that even a hardened criminal can be changed by kindness.

Aksionov's Wife

She is a loving, anxious wife whose dream of her husband's grey hair foreshadows his fate. She petitions the Czar for him, but in her despair she, too, doubts his innocence, a doubt that breaks his heart and turns him wholly towards God.

Themes of the Story

  • Forgiveness: Aksionov finds peace only when he forgives the man who ruined his life.
  • Faith in God: When human justice fails, Aksionov puts his trust in God, who "sees the truth" and gives justice in His own time.
  • Injustice and the failure of human justice: An innocent man is convicted on circumstantial evidence and suffers for twenty-six years.
  • Patience and suffering: Suffering, accepted with patience, purifies Aksionov's soul.
  • Repentance and the power of goodness: Aksionov's mercy awakens Makar's conscience and makes him confess.
  • Fate: The wife's dream comes true, as if his destiny had been written in advance.

Before Reading

a. What does the title of the story mean?

Answer: The title means that God always knows the truth, even when people do not, but He does not reveal it or give justice immediately. He waits for the right time. Truth may be hidden for a long time, but in the end it comes out, just as Makar finally confesses after twenty-six years.

b. Is it fair to punish innocent people in the name of justice?

Answer: No, it is never fair. The very purpose of justice is to protect the innocent and punish the guilty. Punishing an innocent person destroys his life and his family, while the real criminal remains free to commit more crimes. That is why courts should decide only on solid evidence and give the accused a fair chance to defend themselves. As the legal principle says, it is better that many guilty people escape than that one innocent person suffers.

c. Do you believe dreams might predict the terrible fate of a person?

Answer: Scientifically, dreams are the result of our thoughts, fears and experiences, and there is no proof that they can predict the future. Many people in our society, however, believe that some dreams are signs of what is coming. In my view, dreams may sometimes seem to come true by coincidence, especially when we worry about someone, but we should not take decisions only on the basis of dreams. In this story, though, the wife's dream does come true, which gives the tale a sense of fate.

Understanding the Text

a. What bad habits did Aksionov have before his marriage?

Answer: Before his marriage, Aksionov was given to drink, and when he had drunk too much he became riotous (noisy and unruly). After he married, he gave up drinking except now and then.

b. What can be the meaning of his wife's dream?

Answer: In her dream, Aksionov returned from the town with his hair quite grey. It was a warning or foreshadowing of the long suffering that awaited him. It meant that he would grow old before he returned, or that he would never return as the young man he was. It came true: after twenty-six years in a Siberian prison, his hair turned white as snow, and he died there as an old man.

c. Why did Aksionov think of killing himself?

Answer: After meeting Makar Semyonich and realising that he was the real murderer, Aksionov lay awake all night. Memories of his wife, his small children, his young and merry self, his arrest, flogging and twenty-six years of prison life rose before him. The thought that all his happiness had been destroyed for a crime he never committed made him so wretched and hopeless that he was ready to kill himself.

d. Why did Makar disclose that he had killed the merchant?

Answer: Makar disclosed his crime because he was deeply moved by Aksionov's kindness. Although Aksionov knew Makar had ruined his life, he did not betray him to the Governor when asked about the tunnel, saving him from a severe flogging. This undeserved mercy awakened Makar's conscience. He said that being flogged was easier to bear than seeing Aksionov, who had pity on him. Overcome with guilt, he confessed and begged for forgiveness.

e. Why doesn't Aksionov wish to return to his family at the end of the story?

Answer: Aksionov had spent twenty-six years in prison. He believed his wife was dead and his children had forgotten him, so he felt he had nowhere to go. More importantly, when he forgave Makar, his heart became light and peaceful. He had found spiritual peace and no longer felt any worldly desire. He no longer wished to leave the prison and only hoped for his last hour to come.

Reference to the Context

a. "Well, old man," repeated the Governor, "tell me the truth: who has been digging under the wall?"

i. Who is that old man?

Answer: The old man is Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov, who has spent twenty-six years in the Siberian prison and is known to the Governor as a truthful, just man.

ii. Which truth is the speaker asking about?

Answer: The Governor is asking who dug the tunnel (hole) under the prison wall to escape. (It was Makar Semyonich.)

iii. Which wall does the speaker mean?

Answer: He means the wall of the prison in Siberia, under which a tunnel had been dug.

b. Describe Aksionov's character.

Answer: Ivan Dmitrich Aksionov is the central character of the story, and he goes through a great change.

At the beginning, he is a young, handsome and successful merchant of Vladimir, fair-haired and curly-headed, full of fun and fond of singing. He had been given to drink in his youth but reformed after marriage. He is carefree and laughs at his wife's dream.

After he is falsely convicted, his character deepens. He is patient and religious: when even his wife suspects him, he puts all his trust in God and stops sending petitions. In prison he is meek, honest and hard-working, making boots, reading The Lives of the Saints and singing in the choir. The prisoners call him "Grandfather" and "The Saint" and trust him to settle their quarrels.

He is also human. When he meets Makar, he feels such anger that he longs for revenge. But he is noble and merciful: he refuses to betray Makar to the Governor, and when Makar confesses, he forgives him, saying, "Maybe I am a hundred times worse than you." Through suffering and forgiveness, Aksionov becomes a truly saintly person who dies at peace.

c. What is the theme of the story?

Answer: The main theme of the story is forgiveness and faith in God's justice. Aksionov is an innocent man who is punished for a crime he did not commit, and human justice fails him completely. Yet he does not lose faith. He believes that only God knows the truth and turns to Him alone.

The story shows that truth cannot stay hidden forever. God "sees the truth, but waits", and after twenty-six years the real murderer confesses. More importantly, it teaches that true peace comes not from revenge but from forgiveness. When Aksionov forgives Makar, his heart becomes light and he is free from hatred, even though he is still in prison. The story also reflects the injustice of a legal system that convicts people on circumstantial evidence, and the power of goodness to awaken a criminal's conscience.

d. Which symbols are used in the story and what do they indicate?

Answer: The main symbols in the story are:

SymbolWhat it indicates
Grey / white hair (the wife's dream)Foreshadowing of Aksionov's long suffering and premature old age; the loss of his youth.
The blood-stained knifeFalse evidence and the failure of human justice; the guilt placed on an innocent man.
The guitar and singingAksionov's carefree, joyful youth, which he loses.
The prison / SiberiaSuffering and punishment, but also the place where his soul is purified.
The Lives of the SaintsHis faith in God and his growth into a saintly man.
The tunnel under the wallThe temptation of revenge, and the test of Aksionov's moral strength.
Makar's confessionThe revelation of truth that God has been "waiting" for.
Aksionov's death before releaseHis final freedom: release from earthly suffering and union with God.

Reference Beyond the Text

a. What role does religion play in Aksionov's life? How does he undergo a spiritual transformation in the story?

Answer: Religion plays the central role in Aksionov's life after his arrest. When the Czar rejects his petition and even his wife suspects him, he realises that only God knows the truth. From then on he gives up all hope of human help and puts his complete trust in God. Religion gives him the strength to bear twenty-six years of unjust punishment without bitterness. In prison, he reads The Lives of the Saints, reads the lessons and sings in the prison church, and prays often.

His spiritual transformation happens in stages. First, he moves from a carefree, worldly merchant to a patient, prayerful prisoner. Then he faces his greatest test when he meets Makar, the real murderer. Anger and the desire for revenge fill his heart, and even prayer cannot give him peace. But when the Governor asks him who dug the tunnel, he chooses mercy over revenge and does not betray Makar. When Makar confesses and begs forgiveness, Aksionov weeps and forgives him completely, even calling himself worse than Makar.

At that moment his heart becomes light, and his longing for home disappears. He is finally free from hatred and worldly desire, at peace with God and himself. His transformation from a man wronged by the world into a saint who forgives his enemy is the heart of the story.

b. What does the story tell us about the existence of an unfair system of justice?

Answer: The story clearly shows how an unfair system of justice can destroy an innocent person's life. Aksionov is arrested only because he stayed at the same inn as the murdered merchant and a blood-stained knife was found in his bag. The police do not consider that someone else could have planted the knife. His frightened face is taken as proof of guilt. No proper investigation is done, the real murderer goes free, and the Czar ignores his petition. He is flogged and sent to Siberia for twenty-six years.

This reflects a system that relies on circumstantial evidence and appearances, where the poor and powerless have no way to prove their innocence, and where punishment is cruel. Such injustice still exists in many parts of the world, including our own country, where innocent people sometimes spend years in jail because of weak investigation, false evidence, corruption or slow courts.

The story teaches that justice must be based on careful investigation and solid evidence, that every accused person deserves a fair trial, and that punishment must never be decided hastily. It also reminds us that while human justice may fail, truth eventually comes out.

Additional Important Questions

1. Why was Aksionov arrested?

Answer: Aksionov was arrested because the merchant with whom he had spent the night at the inn was found with his throat cut. When the police searched his luggage, they found a blood-stained knife in his bag. Since the house had been locked from inside and he had left before dawn, the police believed he was the murderer, and his fear and stammering made him look guilty.

2. How did Aksionov spend his twenty-six years in prison?

Answer: In prison, Aksionov learnt to make boots and with the money he earned bought The Lives of the Saints, which he read whenever there was enough light. On Sundays he read the lessons and sang in the prison choir. He was meek and helpful, so the authorities liked him and the prisoners called him "Grandfather" and "The Saint", making him their spokesman and judge in quarrels.

3. Why did Aksionov not tell the Governor who dug the tunnel?

Answer: Although Aksionov hated Makar and wanted him to pay for his suffering, he thought that if he told, Makar would be flogged almost to death. He was also not completely sure of Makar's guilt, and he felt that revenge would do him no good. Guided by his faith, he said, "It is not God's will that I should tell!"

4. What is the irony at the end of the story?

Answer: The irony is that when the truth is finally revealed and the order for Aksionov's release arrives after twenty-six years, he is already dead. The justice he waited for comes too late for his worldly life. Yet he dies at peace, having forgiven his enemy, so in a spiritual sense he has already found freedom.

5. Justify the title "God Sees the Truth, but Waits".

Answer: The title is suitable because it sums up the story's message. God knew all along that Aksionov was innocent and Makar was guilty, but He did not reveal the truth at once. He "waited" for twenty-six years, during which Aksionov's soul was purified through suffering, and Makar was finally brought to repent through Aksionov's mercy. In the end the truth came out, showing that God's justice may be delayed but is never denied.

More Class 11 English Notes

Post a Comment