Table of Content

Identity Crisis in Immigrants by Jonathan Yardley: Class 11 English Unit 18 Questions and Answers | NEB

Class 11 English (NEB) · Section One: Language Development · Unit 18
Unit 18: Immigration and Identity
Reading text: Identity Crisis in Immigrants by Jonathan Yardley

In this post, you will find complete answers to Unit 18: Immigration and Identity from the Language Development section of the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook. It includes a summary of the reading text Identity Crisis in Immigrants, answers to Before You Read, Ways with Words, Comprehension and Critical Thinking, model answers for Writing, Grammar rules with solved exercises, and guidance for Listening, Speaking and Project Work.

What this unit covers

Reading: Identity Crisis in Immigrants (Jonathan Yardley's review of V.S. Naipaul's Half a Life)

Vocabulary: crossword; word meanings; homophones

Writing: a book or film review

Grammar: reported speech (statements, questions, commands)

Listening: a film review

Speaking: reporting

Project: report on homesickness

About the Text

The reading is a book review by Jonathan Yardley (1939–2025), a Pulitzer Prize-winning American critic who wrote for The Washington Post. He reviews Half a Life (2001), the 13th novel of V.S. Naipaul (1932–2018), the Trinidad-born British writer of Indian origin who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 2001. The novel tells the story of Willie Chandran, a man of mixed caste background who moves from India to London and then to Africa, always searching for "a proper place in the world". The review focuses on the identity crisis of people who feel they belong nowhere.

Summary

Yardley says that Half a Life continues Naipaul's lifelong interest in cultural and racial identity, but its tone is spare, melancholy and ironic, unlike the lively quality of his best work such as A House for Mr. Biswas.

The heart of the novel is a scene in Africa where Willie sees a "big light-eyed" tiler being abused by his Portuguese boss. Willie's lover Ana explains that the man is the illegitimate son of an African mother and a rich Portuguese father. Willie keeps wondering, "Who will rescue that man? Who will avenge him?" This question is the central motif: the novel is about a man "who appeared to have no proper place in the world".

Willie's background: Willie was born in India. His father, a high-caste man in the maharaja's revenue service, answered Gandhi's call for sacrifice by marrying "the lowest person I could find", a dark-skinned woman of a backward caste. The British writer Somerset Maugham later portrays the father as a spiritual, self-sacrificing man, a role he knows is false but slips into easily. The real victims are the children, Willie and his sister. Unhappy in India, loving his mother and despising his father, Willie wins a scholarship to a second-rate college in London and escapes.

In London: Willie feels ignorant at first, but he learns fast. He begins to understand how the British had looked down on his father, and his contempt turns into empathy. His great revelation is that the old rules of India no longer bind him: nobody in London knows his background, so he is free to remake himself, his past and his ancestry. He invents a new past, enjoys bohemian immigrant life for a while, writes scripts for the BBC and publishes a small book of stories based on borrowed film plots. When his writing begins to lead him towards painful truths, he stops.

Ana and Africa: His book is ignored except by Ana, a young woman of mixed African and Portuguese background, who writes that his stories reflect her own life. With her, for the first time, Willie feels completely accepted. He follows her to her Portuguese colony in Africa, where he lives for many years. There he discovers that it is a "half-and-half world", where many people secretly consider themselves "second rank". Their place in the world is as uncertain as his own, but Willie, caught up in his fears and resentments, fails to see that this is a universal condition.

Yardley says that it is Naipaul, not Willie, who makes this point, subtly and with nuance. The novel uses an omniscient narrator, perhaps to separate Naipaul from Willie, though the point of view is Willie's. Willie is intelligent but blind to the full truth about himself: worldly yet self-deceiving, a state of mind familiar to many of us.

Main message

  • People of mixed or divided backgrounds often struggle to find their "proper place in the world".
  • Migrants may reinvent their identities, but they cannot fully escape their past.
  • The feeling of being "half and half" or "second rank" is a universal human condition.
  • Self-deception can stop us from seeing the truth about ourselves.

Before You Read

a. Who are immigrants? Do you think that people living in foreign countries have no identity?

Answer: Immigrants are people who leave their own country and come to live permanently in another country, usually for work, education, safety or a better life.

No, people living in foreign countries do have an identity. They carry their nationality, ethnicity, language, religion, culture and values with them, and they also gain new identities, such as being a student, worker or citizen of the new country. However, they sometimes face an identity crisis: they feel they do not fully belong to either their homeland or their new country.

b. Complete the bubbles with the terms related to identity.

Answer: Identity can be linked with: ethnicity, nationality, religion, language, culture, gender, caste, race, family, name, age, occupation, social class, values and beliefs, citizenship, region and traditions.

Ways with Words

A. Crossword puzzle

ClueMeaningAnswer
Across 2as is certain to happeninevitably
Across 4famous and respectedeminent
Across 6a temporary staysojourn
Across 7knowing everythingomniscient
Down 1the state of being preoccupiedpreoccupation
Down 3anxious or fearful that something bad will happenapprehensive
Down 5a person of mixed white and black ancestrymulatto (an old term, now considered offensive)

B. Meanings as used in the text

WordMeaning
melancholysad and thoughtful; full of gloom
elusivedifficult to understand, describe or catch
motifa main idea or theme that is repeated in a work of art or literature
disdainthe feeling that someone is not worthy of respect; contempt
fabricateto invent something false in order to deceive
intoxicateto make someone very excited or delighted (here: "intoxicating" = thrilling)
resentmentbitterness or anger at being treated unfairly

C. Homophones

Yes. In the joke, "Board" (a group of people who manage an organisation) and "bored" (tired and uninterested) have the same pronunciation but different meanings and spellings. They are homophones.

D. Choose the right word

Answer
aCan you bury the box in the back garden?
bAlex could not break the branch off the tree.
cWhose pencil is on the floor?
dWe have got very few tasks left.
eSome tribes worship their gods before they pray.
fDamn it. Everything is messed up.
gWhat a wonderful lesson the professor presented.

Note

In (e), "prey" (to hunt) could also make sense if the sentence means that tribes worship before hunting. In the context of worship, "pray" is the expected answer.

Comprehension

a. How is Willie Chandran different from the rest of his family?

Answer: Willie is born of a mixed marriage: his father is a high-caste Brahmin, and his mother is from a backward caste. Unlike his father, who stays in India and accepts the false image of a "spiritual, self-sacrificing" man, Willie despises his father, loves his mother, and leaves India to find his own identity in London and Africa. He is restless and searching, while his father settled into a comfortable role.

b. Who is the main character of Half a Life? How is he described?

Answer: The main character is Willie Chandran. He is described as a man "who appeared to have no proper place in the world", just letting the days go by and hoping something would happen to take him where he should go. He is intelligent and of good character, but blind to the full truth about himself: worldly yet self-deceiving.

c. Why does Willie leave India?

Answer: Willie leaves India because he is bitterly unhappy there. His mixed-caste birth gives him a divided identity; he loves his mother but despises his father. When he gets a scholarship to a college in London, he takes the chance to escape.

d. What is the revelation that Willie begins to feel in college and in London?

Answer: He realises that the old rules of India no longer bind him and that freedom is his for the asking. Nobody in London knows the rules of his home society, so he is free to present himself as he wishes: he can remake himself, his past and his ancestry.

e. Why does Willie accompany Ana?

Answer: Willie accompanies Ana because with her, for the first time in his life, he feels completely accepted. She behaves as if she has always known and liked him; there is "nothing to push against, no misgiving to overcome, no feeling of distance". So when she returns to her Portuguese African country, he goes with her.

f. What is the central issue Naipaul has raised in the novel?

Answer: The central issue is the crisis of identity: the search for a proper place in the world by people of mixed or divided backgrounds, such as migrants and the children of mixed marriages. Naipaul shows that the sense of being "half and half", uncertain and "second rank", is in fact a universal human condition.

Critical Thinking

a. What kind of divided identity is depicted in Half a Life? How do characters in the novel try to create new identities for themselves? Explain.

Answer: The novel shows several kinds of divided identity. Willie is divided by caste, being the son of a high-caste father and a low-caste mother; by place, belonging fully neither to India, England nor Africa; and by culture, standing between East and West. Ana is of mixed African and Portuguese blood, and the tiler is the illegitimate child of a Portuguese father and an African mother. Many people in the African colony are "half-and-half", considering themselves "second rank".

The characters try to create new identities in different ways. Willie's father accepts the false role of a spiritual, self-sacrificing man created for him by Somerset Maugham. Willie uses the freedom of London to fabricate a new past and ancestry, writes stories borrowed from films to hide his own life, and later tries to find acceptance by living with Ana in Africa. Ana and her friends try to hold on to the status of being "Portuguese" in a colonial society. But none of them fully escapes the past; their new identities remain incomplete, like "half a life".

b. Discuss the similarities between the author and the protagonist of the novel.

Answer: There are several similarities between V.S. Naipaul and Willie Chandran:

Indian origin and displacement: Naipaul was born in Trinidad to a family of Indian origin, and Willie is born in India. Both are outsiders who grew up between cultures.

Escape to England through a scholarship: Naipaul went to Oxford on a scholarship in 1950, and Willie goes to London on a scholarship in the 1950s.

Writing career in London: Both begin their careers in London, working for the BBC and trying to write stories.

Search for identity: Both are preoccupied with questions of cultural and racial identity, rootlessness and belonging.

Life in many countries: Naipaul travelled widely in Africa, Asia and the Caribbean, and Willie lives in India, England and Africa.

However, Naipaul uses an omniscient narrator to keep some distance from Willie. Unlike Willie, Naipaul became a highly successful writer and won the Nobel Prize.

Writing

B. Write a review of a book or film you have recently read or watched.

Sample book review: Palpasa Café

Title: Palpasa Café  Author: Narayan Wagle

Publisher: Nepalaya, Kathmandu  First published: 2005 (in Nepali; translated into English in 2008)  Genre: Fiction (novel)

 

About the author: Narayan Wagle is a well-known Nepali journalist and former editor of Kantipur daily. Palpasa Café, his first novel, won the Madan Puraskar in 2005 and became one of the best-selling Nepali novels.

Summary: The story is told by a writer who meets Drishya, a painter, who tells him his story. In Goa, Drishya meets Palpasa, a young Nepali woman who has grown up in America, and they fall in love. Palpasa returns to Nepal to make a documentary about the effects of the armed conflict. Drishya travels to the hills to find a place for his dream project, "Palpasa Café", and sees the violence of the Maoist insurgency and the army. Tragedy follows, and the novel ends in mystery and sadness.

Themes and style: The novel explores love, art, war and the suffering of ordinary people caught between two armed sides during Nepal's conflict. Wagle's journalistic eye gives realistic pictures of villages, displacement and fear, while the love story adds emotion. The language is simple, poetic and easy to follow, and the story-within-a-story structure keeps readers curious.

My opinion: Palpasa Café is a moving and thought-provoking novel. It made me understand the pain of the conflict period, which my parents often talk about. Some parts move slowly, but the ending is powerful.

Rating: 4/5. I recommend it to all young Nepalis who want to understand recent history through literature.

Tip

Follow the format in the book: introduction (title, author, publisher, date, genre), the author's background, a short summary without giving away every surprise, themes and style, and your own opinion with reasons. For a film review, add the director, release date, cast, and comments on acting, music and camera work.

Grammar: Reported Speech

Quick rules

Backshift of tenses (when the reporting verb is past): present simple → past simple; present continuous → past continuous; present perfect / past simple → past perfect; will → would; can → could.

Pronouns and time/place words change: I → he/she; my → his/her; today → that day; tomorrow → the next day; yesterday → the day before; here → there; this → that.

Questions: wh- questions → asked + wh-word + statement order (She asked what I wanted). Yes/no questions → asked + if/whether (He asked if I lived near there).

Commands and requests: told / asked / ordered + (not) to + verb (I told Joe not to be late).

No backshift is needed for general truths, for "had + past participle", for "would/could/should", or for second conditionals.

Change into indirect speech

Answer
aShe said that while she had been having dinner, the phone had rung.
bMy friend asked where they were staying.
cJamila said that she travelled a lot in her job.
dShe told me that they had lived in China for five years.
eHe asked me if I liked ice-cream.
fThey exclaimed with joy that they had won the match.
gHe said that he had tried everything without success, but that that new medicine was great.
hSony said that she went to the gym next to my house.
iHe told us to be quiet after 10 o'clock.
jHe said that he didn't want to go to the party unless he invited him.
kHe told me that he would see me the next day if I met him.
lShe said that if she were me, she would give up the work. / She advised me to give up the work.

Listening

A. Look at the picture and guess the answers.

Answer: a. I see people watching a film in a cinema hall, sitting in rows with snacks, looking at a big screen.

b. Yes, I watch movies because they entertain me, help me relax, teach me about different cultures and life lessons, and improve my English listening.

c. I like adventure, science fiction and comedy films. I also enjoy Nepali films based on real social issues.

About B and C (audio)

These exercises are based on the audio film review of "Fun in the City", which is not printed in the textbook. Listen in class and choose the answers: how the speaker feels about the film, why he gives the review, where the characters travel, what they do, which film he suggests instead, how long fans waited, what he admires and what he feels attached to. Then list the film words he uses.

C. List words that people use to talk about films.

Answer: Common film words: plot, storyline, script, scene, sequel, prequel, character, cast, star, lead role, director, producer, screenplay, soundtrack, special effects, cinematography, climax, ending, genre, comedy, thriller, horror, drama, blockbuster, flop, box office, review, critic, rating, trailer, premiere, award-winning, gripping, boring, overrated, must-watch.

Speaking: Reporting

A. Report what your friend said

DirectReported
a. I like this song.My friend said that she liked that song.
b. Where is your sister?She asked me where my sister was.
c. I don't speak Italian.She said that she didn't speak Italian.
d. Say hello to Jim.She told me to say hello to Jim.
e. The film began at seven o'clock.She said that the film had begun at seven o'clock.
f. Don't play on the grass, boys.She told the boys not to play on the grass.
g. Where have you spent your money?She asked me where I had spent my money.
h. I never make mistakes.She said that she never made mistakes.
i. Does she know Robert?She asked me if she knew Robert.
j. Don't try this at home.She told me not to try that at home.

B. Sample report about a partner

I talked to Sabina. She told me that her favourite sport was badminton. She said that she was planning to visit Ilam during her next vacation. She said that her best friend was Priya and that she had known her for six years. She told me that she liked Nepali folk music and pop songs. She said that she had watched a film with her family the evening before. She said that she wanted to improve her English by reading newspapers and watching English films, and that she wanted to become a doctor in the future.

C. Report using the verbs from the list

Answer
aHe assured me that there would be no delay.
bShe warned me not to mention it again.
cMy brother admitted taking (having taken) the money.
dNeha accused me of taking her money.
eShe insisted that I should have dinner with her.
fHe denied stealing anyone's bag.
gShe claimed that she had closed the door.
hThe receptionist explained that the doctor was out to lunch.
iThe guard pointed out that the van had been in the car park all day.

Project Work

Meet a person who has been living far away from their family for a long time. Ask about their feelings of homesickness. Then write a report and present it in class.

Sample report

Report on Homesickness: An Interview with a Migrant Worker

 

Introduction: For this project, I interviewed Mr. Dil Bahadur Rana, 34, from our village, who has worked in Malaysia for eight years. He was home on a two-month leave. I asked him about his life abroad and his feelings of homesickness.

Findings: Mr. Rana said that he works in a furniture factory for ten to twelve hours a day. He told me that the first year was the hardest: he could not understand the language, the food was different, and he cried almost every night. He said that he missed his wife, his two children and his old parents the most, especially during Dashain and Tihar, when he had to work while his family celebrated without him. "When I see the children playing on video call, my heart breaks," he said. He also said that he had missed his father's funeral because he could not get leave.

He explained that he copes with homesickness by talking to his family on video calls every evening, cooking dal-bhat with his Nepali roommates, and listening to Nepali folk songs. He said that the Nepali community there helps each other, especially when someone is sick.

Conclusion: The interview showed that behind every remittance there is a story of loneliness and sacrifice. Mr. Rana said that he wants to return to Nepal for good and start a small poultry farm if he can save enough money. He suggested that the government should create jobs at home so that young people do not have to leave their families.

More Class 11 English Notes

Post a Comment