Unit 7: Ecology and Development
Reading text: Foresters without Diplomas by Wangari Maathai
In this post, you will find complete answers to Unit 7: Ecology and Development from the Language Development section of the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook. It includes a summary of the reading text Foresters without Diplomas, answers to Before You Read, Ways with Words, Comprehension and Critical Thinking, model answers for Writing, Grammar rules with solved exercises, and guidance for Listening, Speaking and Project Work.
What this unit covers
Reading: Foresters without Diplomas (an autobiographical essay by Wangari Maathai)
Vocabulary: word meanings; negative and other prefixes
Writing: personal letter (reply); essay on community forests
Grammar: transitive, intransitive and linking verbs
Listening: an interview on environmental governance
Speaking: asking for and giving opinions
Project: Environment Day speech; story of a local environmentalist
About the Text
"Foresters without Diplomas" is an autobiographical essay by Wangari Maathai (1940–2011), a Kenyan biologist, environmentalist and political activist. She founded the Green Belt Movement in 1977, which helped women plant tens of millions of trees across Kenya. In 2004 she became the first African woman to win the Nobel Peace Prize for her contribution to sustainable development, democracy and peace. In this essay she tells how the movement began, how ordinary rural women became "foresters without diplomas", and what problems she faced.
Summary
The Green Belt Movement started in Maathai's backyard. During a political campaign with her then husband, she tried to create jobs for poor people by having them clean the constituency and plant trees, with payment from richer people. The plan failed because the poor needed money immediately and she had none to pay them in advance. She dropped the project but kept the idea.
In 1976 she joined the National Council of Women of Kenya. There she learned about the problems women faced: lack of firewood, malnutrition, lack of food and water, unemployment and soil erosion. She saw these as the results of "maldevelopment". She decided to work with women, because women are most affected by these problems and care most about children and the future.
At first they invited professional foresters to teach the women, but the foresters, with their diplomas, made a simple job complicated. So the women were taught to use common sense: collect seeds from the neighbourhood and recognise seedlings. They became "foresters without diplomas".
The movement began on World Environment Day, 5 June 1977, with seven trees, of which two Nandi flame trees still stand. By 1988 there were 10 million surviving trees and over 1,500 tree nurseries, 99 per cent run by women. The greatest achievement was that the women became independent, skilled and empowered. Women received a small payment for every surviving seedling. Maathai fears that as money comes in, men will join more for economic benefit than for commitment. The movement succeeded where women farm the land, but failed among nomadic communities, where trees are most needed.
The movement tried to spread to other African countries but could not follow up, because the Kenyan government turned against it after Maathai criticised a plan to build a large building in a Nairobi public park. The government took back the office it had given, and the headquarters moved back to her house. She never received government funding; support came from women around the world, the UN Development Fund for Women ($100,000 in 1981), the Danish Voluntary Fund, the Norwegian Agency for International Development and the African Development Foundation.
Maathai, a biologist, would like to return to academic life one day. She earns far less than she could, and some people think her a fool. Her greatest satisfaction is the change in the landscape; her greatest disappointment is that people and political systems limit human potential. Because she criticised the leadership, she was called subversive. She believes that a desire to work and common sense matter more than imposed knowledge. Her final message: never lose hope; "One person can make the difference."
Main message
- Ordinary people, especially women, can protect the environment with common sense, without formal training.
- Real development must be community-based and in harmony with nature; otherwise it becomes "maldevelopment".
- Empowering women brings change to families, communities and the environment.
- One determined person with an idea can start a movement that changes society.
Before You Read
a. What are the children doing in the picture?
Answer: The children in the picture are planting trees (saplings). They are digging the soil, placing young plants in the ground and watering them, which shows that they are helping to protect the environment.
b. Share a couple of things that you and your friends have done to preserve or protect the environment in your community.
Answer: My friends and I have done several things for our community. On World Environment Day, our school's eco-club planted about fifty saplings along the road near our school and took turns watering them. Every month we join a cleanliness campaign to collect plastic waste from the riverbank and the temple area. We also run an awareness programme asking shopkeepers and neighbours to use cloth bags instead of plastic bags. These small efforts have made our area cleaner and greener.
c. What does the title mean? Discuss with your friends.
Answer: A forester is an expert in planting and managing forests, who usually has a formal degree or diploma in forestry. "Foresters without Diplomas" refers to the poor, uneducated rural women of Kenya who learned to collect seeds, grow seedlings and plant millions of trees using common sense and experience, without any formal training. The title suggests that practical knowledge and dedication can be as valuable as formal qualifications.
Ways with Words
A. Match the words with their meanings
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| a. constituency | iv. electoral district |
| b. pursue | iii. to follow in an effort to overtake or capture |
| c. nomadic | ii. living the life of roaming |
| d. anatomy | vi. art of studying the different parts of any organised body |
| e. subversive | i. seeking or intended to overthrow an established system or institution |
| f. infiltrate | v. to enter or gain access to an organisation, place, etc. secretly and gradually |
B–C. Prefixes: two more words with each, used in sentences
Quick note
mal- = bad or faulty; mis- = wrongly; un-, in-, il-, im-, ir-, dis-, non- = not or the opposite of; pre- = before; re- = again; de- = down, away or reverse.
il- comes before l (illegal), im- before m and p (immoral, impolite), ir- before r (irregular).
| Prefix | New words | Sentences |
|---|---|---|
| mal- | malnutrition, malfunction | Malnutrition is common among children in poor families. • The machine stopped because of a malfunction. |
| mis- | misunderstand, misuse | Please don't misunderstand me. • We should not misuse public property. |
| un- | unkind, unknown | It was unkind of him to laugh at her. • An unknown person called me last night. |
| in- | incorrect, invisible | Two of my answers were incorrect. • Germs are invisible to the naked eye. |
| pre- | prehistoric, prepay | Dinosaurs lived in prehistoric times. • You have to prepay for this mobile service. |
| il- | illogical, illegitimate | His argument was completely illogical. • The court declared the election illegitimate. |
| dis- | disagree, disappear | I disagree with your opinion. • The sun disappeared behind the clouds. |
| im- | impossible, impatient | Nothing is impossible for a hard-working person. • Don't be impatient; your turn will come. |
| re- | rewrite, rebuild | The teacher asked me to rewrite the essay. • Many houses were rebuilt after the earthquake. |
| ir- | irregular, irreplaceable | Irregular study leads to poor results. • A mother's love is irreplaceable. |
| de- | deforestation, decode | Deforestation causes floods and landslides. • Can you decode this message? |
| non- | non-violent, non-smoker | Gandhi led a non-violent movement. • My father is a non-smoker. |
Comprehension
a. What did Maathai decide to do for the community?
Answer: Maathai decided to create jobs for the poor people who had helped in her political campaign. They would clean their constituency, plant trees and shrubs and clean the homes of richer people, and get paid for these services. Later, she decided to work with women to plant trees to solve problems such as lack of firewood and soil erosion.
b. Mention the problems faced by women in Kenya.
Answer: Women in Kenya faced problems of lack of firewood, malnutrition, lack of food and adequate water, unemployment and soil erosion. They also lacked building and fencing materials, and their water systems needed protection.
c. Why did the speaker go to the women to talk about planting trees?
Answer: She went to the women because she herself was a woman working in a women's organisation, and because women are the ones most affected by problems such as lack of firewood, water and food. Women are also concerned about children and the future, so they would be most committed to planting and caring for trees.
d. What is the most important achievement of the movement described in the text?
Answer: Although the movement planted about 10 million surviving trees and set up over 1,500 nurseries, the most important achievement was that the women became independent and empowered. They acquired knowledge and techniques, ran the nurseries themselves and taught each other.
e. Why were the foresters' ways not helpful to the women for planting trees?
Answer: The foresters had diplomas and used complicated, technical methods for a very simple task like looking for seeds and planting trees. Their methods were difficult for ordinary rural women to follow, so the women were taught to use common sense instead.
f. When and how did she start the Green Belt Movement?
Answer: She started the Green Belt Movement on World Environment Day, 5 June 1977, by planting the first seven trees. The idea had begun earlier in her backyard, and she developed it through the National Council of Women of Kenya, starting with one tree nursery in the backyard of the Council's office.
g. Why do the donors want to provide money to the women?
Answer: Donors want to provide money because the women's efforts are providing results: millions of trees have survived, nurseries are running well and the environment is improving. Successful, result-oriented work attracts financial support.
h. What happened when the speaker criticised the political leadership?
Answer: When she criticised the government (for planning a big building in a Nairobi public park), the government took away the office it had given the movement, and the headquarters had to move back to her house. She was portrayed as subversive, felt constrained, and the movement could not follow up its work in other African countries.
i. Mention the agencies that supported her movement.
Answer: The movement was supported by women all over the world (who sent small cheques), the United Nations Development Fund for Women ($100,000 in 1981), the Danish Voluntary Fund, the Norwegian Agency for International Development and, in the US, the African Development Foundation, which helped make a film about the movement in 1985.
Critical Thinking
a. Do you think that the title "Foresters without Diplomas" is suitable to the essay? How?
Answer: Yes, the title is very suitable. The essay is about how ordinary rural women in Kenya, without any formal education in forestry, planted and cared for millions of trees. Maathai first invited trained foresters, but their methods were too complicated. The women, using only common sense, learned to collect seeds, recognise seedlings and run nurseries. In Maathai's words, "They are really foresters without a diploma."
The title also carries the main message of the essay: practical knowledge, a desire to work and common sense are more important than certificates. It honours the women who are the real heroes of the Green Belt Movement and makes readers curious, so it is both meaningful and attractive.
b. Can a person make a difference in a society? Discuss with an example from a person who has made a difference in your society.
Answer: Yes, one person can make a big difference. Every great change begins with the idea and courage of a single person, as Maathai's backyard project grew into a movement that planted millions of trees.
In our society, Mahabir Pun is a fine example. A teacher from Myagdi, he connected remote mountain villages to the internet using wireless technology, bringing education, telemedicine and business opportunities to people who had never seen a computer. His Nepal Wireless Networking Project inspired many young people to work for their villages. He received the Ramon Magsaysay Award in 2007.
Similarly, Anuradha Koirala rescued thousands of girls from human trafficking through Maiti Nepal, and Pushpa Basnet gave homes and education to children of imprisoned parents. These examples show that when one person acts with determination and honesty, others join in, and society changes.
Writing
A. Parts of a personal letter
| Part | In the letter |
|---|---|
| Sender's address | 27 Barnes Avenue, London |
| Date | March 1st, 2020 |
| Greeting (salutation) | Dear Mrs. MacDonald, |
| Complimentary close | Yours sincerely, |
B. Suppose you are MacDonald. Write a reply to Sandra Shaw.
14 Park Lane, London
March 5th, 2020
Dear Ms. Shaw,
Thank you for your letter of 1st March. I am glad that you like the flat, and I am sorry to hear about the problems you have been having.
I agree that some of the furniture is quite old. I will replace the armchairs and the dining table by the end of this month. Please let me know if any other items need to be replaced.
I am particularly concerned about the heating, as I do not want you to be cold or to spend so much on electric fires. I have asked a heating engineer to check the central heating system next Monday. I will also have the windows repaired so that they fit properly and keep the wind out.
As for the kitchen, thank you for kindly offering to paint it yourselves. I will be happy to pay for the paint. Just choose the colour you like and send me the bill.
I would like to come and look at the flat myself on Saturday, 7th March, at about 11 a.m., if that is convenient for you. Please let me know if another time suits you better.
Thank you for your patience and for taking good care of the flat.
Yours sincerely,
Margaret MacDonald
C. Write an essay on "The Community Forest in Nepal". Describe how these community forests have contributed to maintain ecology in our environment.
Sample essay: The Community Forest in Nepal
Forests are the lungs of the earth and an important natural resource for Nepal. In the past, forests were nationalised and controlled by the government, but this led to rapid deforestation, because local people felt no ownership. To solve this problem, Nepal introduced the community forestry programme in the late 1970s, and the Forest Act of 1993 gave local communities the right to manage nearby forests through Community Forest User Groups (CFUGs). Today there are more than 22,000 user groups managing about one-third of Nepal's forests, and Nepal's community forestry is admired around the world as a model of people-centred conservation.
Community forests have contributed greatly to maintaining ecology. Bare hills in the middle hills have turned green again, and national forest cover has increased to about 45 per cent. Trees hold the soil and reduce landslides, soil erosion and floods. They protect water sources, so springs that had dried up have started flowing again. Community forests provide homes for birds, animals and plants, protecting biodiversity, and they absorb carbon dioxide, helping to fight climate change.
Community forests also bring social and economic benefits. Local people get firewood, fodder, timber and herbs in a sustainable way. User groups earn income by selling forest products and through eco-tourism, and they spend it on schools, roads, drinking water and support for poor and marginalised families. Women and Dalits take part in decision-making, which has strengthened local democracy.
However, there are still challenges, such as illegal logging, forest fires, unequal sharing of benefits and political interference. These can be solved through good governance, transparency and awareness. In conclusion, community forests show that when people are given ownership and responsibility, they protect nature. They are the green pride of Nepal and must be preserved for future generations.
Grammar: Transitive, Intransitive and Linking Verbs
Quick rules
Transitive verb: needs an object to complete its meaning. Ask "what?" or "whom?" after the verb. She bought a book. (bought what? a book)
Intransitive verb: does not take an object. It may be followed by an adverb. The baby slept peacefully. The car stopped suddenly.
Linking verb: connects the subject to a complement (an adjective or noun) that describes it: be, become, seem, appear, look, feel, smell, taste, sound, grow, turn. The soup tastes good. He became a doctor.
Some verbs can be more than one type: He grew tomatoes (transitive). The child grew quickly (intransitive). She grew tired (linking).
B. The difference, with examples
| Type | What it does | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Transitive | Takes a direct object (a noun or pronoun that receives the action). | Ram kicked the ball. • I wrote a letter. • She loves her parents. |
| Intransitive | Does not take an object; the action stays with the subject. | The baby cried. • Birds fly. • He arrived late. |
| Linking | Joins the subject to a word that describes or renames it; it shows a state, not an action. | She is a nurse. • The milk turned sour. • You look tired. |
C. Identify the verb and its type
| Verb | Type | |
|---|---|---|
| a. His father looks handsome. | looks | linking |
| b. Bhawana drinks milk every day. | drinks | transitive (object: milk) |
| c. He became a watchman. | became | linking |
| d. This bread smells good. | smells | linking |
| e. The dog barked loudly. | barked | intransitive |
| f. He chased the dog. | chased | transitive (object: the dog) |
| g. My sister swims fast. | swims | intransitive |
| h. He painted a picture. | painted | transitive (object: a picture) |
| i. Radhika always asks questions. | asks | transitive (object: questions) |
| j. Anjana has long hair. | has | transitive (object: long hair) |
Note
In (j), "hair" on the head is uncountable, so the correct form is "Anjana has long hair", not "a long hair".
Listening
A. Look at the picture and answer these questions.
Answer: a. They seem to be talking about the environment and climate change, perhaps in a television interview or discussion programme.
b. I prefer news, documentaries and quiz programmes, because they are informative. I also enjoy nature and travel documentaries.
c. Climate change is the long-term change in the earth's temperature and weather patterns. Because of global warming, glaciers in the Himalayas are melting, rainfall has become irregular, and floods, landslides and droughts are increasing.
d. The main reasons are the burning of fossil fuels (petrol, diesel, coal) in vehicles and industries, deforestation, increasing greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide and methane, and pollution from factories, agriculture and waste.
About B and C (audio)
Exercises B and C are based on the audio interview with Maria Ivanova, which is not printed in the textbook. Listen in class and note: her university and field of work (environmental governance), how she defines environmental governance, whether she sees climate change as a separate issue or connected to other issues, the links among organisations, and why she wants climate issues brought into classrooms.
D. Maria Ivanova is advocating for the education of environmental issues. Why is she doing this? Talk to your classmates.
Answer: She advocates environmental education because climate change is a global problem that affects everyone, and it cannot be solved by governments and international organisations alone. When students learn about the environment in the classroom, they understand the causes and effects of climate change, change their own habits and influence their families and communities. Educated young people become responsible citizens, future leaders and policy-makers who can design and carry out better environmental policies. Education therefore turns knowledge into action.
Speaking: Asking for and Giving Opinions
Useful expressions
Asking: What do you think about...? • What's your view on...? • How do you see...? • Do you think (that)...? • Don't you think (that)...? • Would you agree that...?
Giving: I think / reckon... • In my opinion / view... • I feel that... • As far as I'm concerned... • From my point of view... • Personally, I believe... • As for me, I reckon...
B. Sample opinions on the topics
| Topic | Question | Opinion |
|---|---|---|
| a. educating girls | What do you think about educating girls? | In my opinion, educating a girl means educating a whole family and nation. |
| b. following foreign traditions | What's your view on following foreign traditions? | As far as I'm concerned, we can learn good things from other cultures, but we shouldn't forget our own. |
| c. worshipping god | How do you see worshipping god? | Personally, I believe worship gives people peace of mind, but it should never become blind faith. |
| d. depending on foreign aid | Do you think Nepal should depend on foreign aid? | I don't think so. Too much dependence makes a country weak; we should become self-reliant. |
| e. cheating in exams | Would you agree that cheating in exams is harmful? | Absolutely. From my point of view, cheating gives marks but no knowledge. |
| f. learning English | What do you think about learning English? | I reckon English opens doors to higher education, jobs and global communication. |
| g. speaking several languages | What's your opinion on speaking several languages? | I feel that it sharpens the mind and helps us understand different people. |
| h. engaging in corruption | How do you see corruption? | In my view, corruption is the biggest obstacle to Nepal's development. |
| i. brain drain | Don't you think brain drain is a serious problem? | Yes, I believe it is. Our skilled youth should get good opportunities at home. |
| j. being drunkards | What do you think about drinking too much alcohol? | As for me, I think it ruins health, families and society. |
Sushma: What do you think about brain drain, Prakash?
Prakash: Well, I reckon it is a serious problem. Thousands of young people leave Nepal every day.
Sushma: I see. But don't you think they also send money home?
Prakash: That's true, but in my view, we lose their skills and energy. The government should create jobs here.
Project Work
a. Imagine that you are a chief guest of the programme organised by a local government on the occasion of the Environment Day. Write a 10-minute speech and deliver it to the class.
Sample speech: Our Environment, Our Future
Respected chairperson of the municipality, ward chairpersons, teachers, guests, and my dear friends, good morning to you all.
I feel honoured to be the chief guest at this programme on the occasion of World Environment Day, which is celebrated every year on 5 June. This day reminds us that the earth is our only home, and that protecting it is not a choice but a duty.
Friends, look around us. Our rivers, which were once clean, are now full of plastic and sewage. The air of our cities is so polluted that we have to wear masks. Our forests are being cut down for roads and buildings, and our hills suffer from landslides every monsoon. The snow on our Himalayas is melting because of global warming. Farmers in our villages say that rain no longer comes at the right time. These are not distant problems; they are happening in our own community.
Most of these problems are caused by human beings: by our greed, carelessness and unplanned development. But the good news is that if humans have caused the problem, humans can also solve it. Nepal has shown the world an excellent example through community forestry. Our once-bare hills are green again because ordinary people decided to protect them. Wangari Maathai of Kenya started with just seven trees in 1977 and inspired women to plant millions. One person, one family and one community can make a difference.
So what can we do? First, let us plant trees and take care of them until they grow. Second, let us say no to plastic bags and carry cloth bags instead. Third, let us manage our waste: separate organic and plastic waste and make compost at home. Fourth, let us save water and electricity and use public transport, bicycles or walk for short distances. Finally, let us spread awareness, because change begins when people understand the problem.
I request the local government to provide waste-collection services in every ward, protect our water sources, and make green spaces and parks for our children. I request teachers to make environmental education practical, and I request students to be the green ambassadors of their homes.
Let us remember the old saying: "We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors; we borrow it from our children." Let us return it to them in a better condition. Today, let us all promise to do at least one thing for our environment every day.
Thank you all for listening. Have a green and happy Environment Day!
b. Identify a person from your community who has worked on environmental protection. Write a story of that person incorporating the efforts s/he made to change things and attitudes of people.
Sample story: The Green Grandmother of Our Village
Twenty years ago, the hill above our village was almost bare. People cut trees for firewood, and every monsoon the landslides washed away fields and the small spring dried up in winter. Nobody seemed to care, until Maya Gurung, a widow in her fifties, decided to act.
She started by planting a few saplings of utis, chilaune and bamboo on the edge of her own field. Villagers laughed at her and said, "What will one old woman change?" But she did not give up. She collected seeds from the forest, raised seedlings in old plastic bags in her courtyard and gave them free to anyone who would plant them. She went from house to house, especially talking to women, explaining how trees would bring back water, fodder and firewood.
Slowly, other women joined her. They formed a mothers' group and later a community forest user group. They made rules: no one would cut green trees, firewood would be collected only from fallen branches, and grazing would be controlled. Maya also persuaded the school to start an eco-club, and every year students planted trees on Environment Day.
Today, the hill is covered with a thick green forest. The spring flows all year round, landslides have stopped, and birds and deer have returned. The user group earns money by selling fodder and seedlings and spends it on the school and drinking water. People who once laughed at Maya now call her "Hariyali Aama", the green grandmother. Her story taught our village that one determined person can change both the land and the attitude of people.
More Class 11 English Notes
← Previous: Unit 6: You May Scoff…
Next: Unit 8: A Few Kind Words for Superstition →
All units and chapters: Class 11 English Guide (NEB) – Language Development and Literature