Unit 8: Humour and Satire
Reading text: A Few Kind Words for Superstition by Robertson Davies
In this post, you will find complete answers to Unit 8: Humour and Satire from the Language Development section of the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook. It includes a summary of the reading text A Few Kind Words for Superstition, answers to Before You Read, Ways with Words, Comprehension and Critical Thinking, model answers for Writing, Grammar rules with solved exercises, and guidance for Listening, Speaking and Project Work.
What this unit covers
Reading: A Few Kind Words for Superstition (an essay by Robertson Davies)
Vocabulary: word meanings; word origins; the prefix super-
Writing: essay on superstitions in your community; argument
Grammar: present simple and present continuous
Listening: preparing an emergency kit
Speaking: suggesting and advising
Project: news article on local superstitions
About the Text
"A Few Kind Words for Superstition" is a light, humorous essay by Robertson Davies (1913–1995), a Canadian novelist, playwright, journalist and professor. Writing from a university, he shows with gentle irony that even highly educated, rational people are secretly superstitious. Instead of attacking superstition, he says a few "kind words" for it: it is old, universal and deeply rooted in the human mind, and even he himself is not free from it.
Summary
Serious people condemn parapsychology, UFOs, miracle cures and instant enlightenment, but they only mildly deplore superstition, perhaps because it has a secret hold on many of them. Few people admit to being superstitious because it suggests ignorance. Yet Davies, who lives in a university, sees superstition "alive and flourishing" among learned people.
According to theologians, superstition has four forms:
- Vain Observances: avoiding walking under a ladder and similar acts. A professor of anthropology threw spilled salt over his left shoulder "to hit the Devil in the eye".
- Divination (consulting oracles): a professor who would never toss a coin settled a university matter by consulting the I Ching, which, Davies notes, often gives excellent advice.
- Idolatry: students place jujus, lucky coins and other charms on their desks in examination halls.
- Improper Worship of the True God: an engineering student worried about a girl tucked a $2 bill under a candlestick in the college chapel, trying to bribe God. It did not work.
Superstition runs like "a submerged river of crude religion" below human consciousness and is probably no more common today than in the past. The word comes from the Latin supersisto, "to stand in terror of the Deity". As formal religion declines, God appears less as a God of Love and more as a threatening power to be pleased and coaxed. Superstition starts early (children avoid cracks in the pavement) and persists even among great men like Dr. Samuel Johnson, who touched posts in the street. Psychoanalysts call it a compulsion neurosis, but naming it does not remove it.
Many superstitions are found across races and religions: charms on doorposts among Jews and Chinese, and the custom of blessing a person who sneezes to protect the soul from the Devil, found in Middle Europe and among Melanesians. Astrology columns are popular even in serious newspapers, and science cannot discredit them, because "When has the heart of man given a damn for science?"
Superstition comes from our yearning to know our fate and to have some control over it. Davies gives examples: his mother killing spiders to bring rain, and an Italian scientist who avoided meeting a priest or nun first thing in the morning. Finally, he admits that as a student he paid a gypsy woman four shillings to touch her "Lucky Baby" at exam time, and he never failed an exam. He did it "for the joke", he thought then; "Now, I am humbler."
Main message
- Superstition is universal and ancient; education alone does not remove it.
- It comes from human fear of the unknown and the wish to control fate.
- Even rational and learned people quietly practise superstitions.
- The writer uses humour and irony, including about himself, to make us look honestly at our own beliefs.
Before You Read
a. What do you see in the picture? What's your quick response to this situation?
Answer: The picture shows a black cat crossing a person's path (a common superstitious sign of bad luck). Many people would stop, turn back or wait for someone else to pass first. My quick response is that it is just a cat crossing the road; it has nothing to do with luck, so I would simply carry on.
b. What is superstition? Do you think luck has a role in your life?
Answer: Superstition is a belief or practice based on fear, magic or chance rather than reason or scientific knowledge, for example believing that a sneeze before leaving home or a black cat crossing the road brings bad luck.
I think luck plays a small role: sometimes things happen by chance, like getting an easy question in an exam. But success mainly depends on hard work, planning and dedication. As the saying goes, "The harder I work, the luckier I get."
Ways with Words
A. Match the words with their meanings
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| a. transcendental | iv. spiritual, non-physical or mystical |
| b. deplore | i. to feel or express strong disapproval of something |
| c. absolve | vi. set free from blame, guilt or responsibility; release |
| d. juju | ii. a charm or fetish used by some West African peoples |
| e. crude | iii. natural state (raw, unrefined) |
| f. chronicle | v. a written record of historical events |
B. Contextual meanings and sentences
| Word | Meaning in the text | Sentence |
|---|---|---|
| condemn | to strongly criticise as wrong | Everyone condemned the attack on the journalist. |
| terror | extreme fear | The villagers ran in terror when the flood came. |
| unbidden | without being asked or invited | Tears came unbidden to her eyes. |
| persist | to continue to exist | Old customs persist in many rural areas. |
| devout | deeply religious | My grandmother is a devout Hindu who prays every morning. |
| banish | to get rid of; drive away | Exercise helps to banish stress. |
| creed | a religious belief or faith | People of every caste and creed live together in Nepal. |
| hasten | to hurry; do something quickly | He hastened to apologise for his mistake. |
| sober | serious and sensible | It was a sober discussion about the country's future. |
| scorn | to refuse or reject with contempt | She scorned his offer of help. |
| yearning | a strong desire or longing | Migrant workers have a deep yearning for home. |
| aloof | distant; not involved | He stood aloof from the noisy crowd. |
| swarthy | dark-skinned | A swarthy fisherman pulled the boat onto the shore. |
| humbler | more modest; less proud | Failure made him humbler and wiser. |
C. Word origins
| Word | Origin | Sentence |
|---|---|---|
| minatory | From Late Latin minatorius, from minari (to threaten). Meaning: threatening. | The dog gave a low, minatory growl. |
| placated | From Latin placare (to calm, soothe). Meaning: made less angry. | The manager placated the angry customer with a refund. |
| cajoled | From French cajoler (to coax, flatter). Meaning: persuaded by flattery or gentle urging. | She cajoled her father into buying her a new phone. |
| antedates | From Latin ante- (before) + datum (date). Meaning: comes before in time. | This temple antedates the Malla period. |
| proliferated | From French prolifère, from Latin proles (offspring) + ferre (to bear). Meaning: increased rapidly in number. | Mobile phone shops have proliferated in every town. |
| philter | From Greek philtron, from philein (to love). Meaning: a love potion. | In the fairy tale, the witch prepared a magic philter. |
D. Words with the prefix super-
| Word | Meaning | Without the prefix |
|---|---|---|
| supermarket | a very large self-service shop | market: an ordinary place to buy and sell |
| superpower | an extremely powerful nation | power: strength or control |
| supernatural | beyond the laws of nature | natural: existing in nature |
| superhuman | having more than normal human ability | human: of ordinary people |
| superstar | an extremely famous performer or player | star: a well-known performer |
Common meaning: the prefix super- means "above, over, beyond, more than or greater than usual". When we remove it, the words lose this idea of excess or superiority and return to their ordinary, basic meaning.
Comprehension
a. According to the author, what are the four types of superstition?
Answer: The four types are: (i) Vain Observances, such as not walking under a ladder or throwing spilled salt over the left shoulder; (ii) Divination, or consulting oracles such as the I Ching; (iii) Idolatry, such as keeping jujus and lucky coins on exam desks; and (iv) Improper Worship of the True God, such as trying to bribe God with a $2 bill on the chapel altar.
b. Which language is the word "superstition" derived from? What does it mean?
Answer: It is derived from Latin, from the word supersisto, which means "to stand in terror of the Deity" (to stand in fear of God).
c. How do psychologists understand superstition?
Answer: Psychologists (psychoanalysts) understand superstition as a compulsion neurosis, a mental condition in which a person feels forced to repeat certain actions, like Dr. Johnson touching posts. But the writer says that calling it a compulsion neurosis does not banish it.
d. How does superstition differ from religion?
Answer: Religion is an organised system of faith, often presenting God as a God of Love, with moral teachings and formal worship. Superstition is a "submerged river of crude religion": irrational beliefs and small rituals based on fear of a watchful, threatening power that must be pleased or bribed. Superstition seems to come from beliefs far older than the religions we know, and those religions have no place for such "comforting little ceremonies".
e. What is the belief of some people in Middle Europe about sneezing?
Answer: Some people of Middle Europe believe that when a person sneezes, his soul leaves his body for that moment, so they quickly bless him so that the Devil cannot seize his soul.
f. In the author's view, why are people so fascinated by superstition?
Answer: In the author's view, people are fascinated by superstition because of their yearning to know their fate and to have some hand in deciding it. Superstition gives people a sense of control and comfort in an uncertain world, and it rises from a deep part of the human mind that reason and science cannot reach.
Critical Thinking
a. What is the key takeaway of this essay? Do you think that this essay is satirical? Why?
Answer: The key takeaway is that superstition is a universal and deep-rooted part of human nature. It exists in every age, culture and class, even among highly educated, rational people, because of our fear of the unknown and our desire to control our fate. Instead of looking down on superstitious people, we should honestly admit our own small superstitions.
Yes, the essay is satirical, but its satire is gentle and humorous. Davies mocks learned professors who claim to be rational but throw salt over their shoulders, consult the I Ching or rely on lucky charms. The student "bribing" God with a cheap $2 bill, and the remark that "perhaps God was proud that week", are ironic. Even the title is ironic: the "kind words" for superstition actually expose human weakness. Finally, he laughs at himself for paying to touch the "Lucky Baby", saying "Now, I am humbler." This self-mockery makes the satire light and friendly rather than bitter.
b. Can education bring change in the belief of superstition? Present your arguments to support your answer.
Answer: Yes, education can bring change, though it cannot remove superstition completely.
Arguments for: Education teaches scientific thinking and the habit of asking "why?". When people learn the real causes of disease, eclipses and natural disasters, they stop blaming witches, planets or spirits. In Nepal, education and awareness have reduced harmful practices such as chhaupadi, witchcraft accusations and taking sick people to shamans instead of hospitals. Educated parents vaccinate their children instead of relying only on charms.
Limits: As Davies shows, even professors and scientists keep small superstitions, because superstition comes from fear and the wish to control the future, not just from ignorance. Harmless habits like carrying a lucky pen may continue.
Conclusion: Education can greatly reduce harmful superstitions and help people make rational decisions, but it must be combined with awareness, law and changes in social attitude.
Writing
a. Write an essay on superstitions that exist in your community in about 250 words.
Sample essay: Superstitions in My Community
Superstition is a belief that is not based on reason or science. Although my community is becoming more educated, many superstitions are still followed, some harmless and some harmful.
Many superstitions are connected with luck. If someone sneezes when a person is leaving home, the person waits for a while before going. A black cat crossing the road or meeting someone with an empty pot on the way is thought to be unlucky, while seeing a full pot of water is a good sign. Cutting nails or hair on Saturday and Tuesday, or sweeping the house in the evening, is believed to bring bad luck. When a crow caws near the house, people expect a guest to come.
Some superstitions are connected with health. Some people still go to a dhami or jhankri for treatment before going to a doctor. A black thread or tika is put on babies to protect them from the "evil eye".
Unfortunately, some superstitions are harmful. In some places, women are kept separate during menstruation, and helpless old women are sometimes accused of being witches. Such beliefs cause pain, injustice and even death.
In my view, harmless customs can be accepted as part of our culture, but harmful superstitions must be removed through education, awareness and strict laws. Schools, the media and educated youth should help people think scientifically, so that our community can move forward with reason, not fear.
b. "Superstition is prevalent in every walk of life." Argue for or against this statement.
Sample answer (for the statement)
I agree that superstition is prevalent in every walk of life. It is not limited to uneducated villagers; it is found among the rich and poor, the educated and uneducated, in villages and cities, and in every profession.
In education, students carry lucky pens, wear lucky clothes or touch a temple bell before exams. In sport, famous players wear the same socks or follow the same ritual before every match. In business, shopkeepers hang lemons and chillies at the door to keep away the evil eye, and companies avoid the number 13. In politics, leaders consult astrologers to choose an auspicious day to take an oath or file their nomination. In daily life, people check horoscopes, avoid certain days for travel, and fix marriages only after matching horoscopes. Even in modern hospitals, some patients tie protective threads on their wrists.
As Robertson Davies shows, even professors and scientists practise small superstitions. This is because superstition is rooted in human fear of the unknown and the desire to control fate, which everyone shares. Therefore, superstition truly exists in every walk of life. Our task is not to laugh at it but to make sure that it does not lead to harmful practices or irrational decisions.
Grammar: Present Simple and Present Continuous
Quick rules
Present simple: facts and general truths (Water boils at 100°C.), habits and routines (I get up at 5.), permanent situations (She lives in Jumla.), timetables (The plane leaves at six.), storytelling and summaries.
Present continuous: actions happening now (The water is boiling.), temporary situations (She is living in Tokyo for a few months.), changing situations (It's getting late.), future arrangements (I'm leaving tomorrow.), annoying habits with "always" (You are always telling lies.).
Stative verbs are not normally used in the continuous: know, believe, understand, like, love, hate, want, need, seem, think (= believe), taste, smell, belong, own.
B. Present simple or present continuous
| Answer | Reason | |
|---|---|---|
| a | Nisha speaks English very well. | permanent ability |
| b | Hurry up! We are waiting for you. | happening now |
| c | Excuse me! Do you speak English? | general ability |
| d | She is having a shower in the bathroom. | happening now |
| e | How often do you read a newspaper? | habit |
| f | I'm sorry, I don't understand. Can you speak more slowly? | stative verb |
| g | You can turn off the radio. I am not listening to it. | now |
| h | I usually get up at 5 o'clock every morning. | routine |
| i | Look! The river is flowing very fast. | happening now |
| j | Amrita doesn't seem very happy at the moment. | stative verb |
C. Correct the verbs where necessary
| Correct sentence | Note | |
|---|---|---|
| a | Water boils at 100°C. | correct: general truth |
| b | The water is boiling. Can you turn it off? | happening now |
| c | I must go now. It is getting late. | changing situation |
| d | This sauce tastes really good. | stative verb |
| e | I think this is your key. | "think" = believe (stative) |
| f | Do you believe in God? | stative verb |
| g | I usually go to school on foot. | correct: habit |
| h | Look! That man is trying to open the door of her car. | happening now |
| i | The moon goes round the earth. | scientific fact |
| j | I'm getting hungry. Let's go and eat. | correct: changing situation |
Listening
A. Look at the picture and answer these questions.
Answer: a. The picture shows an emergency kit: a torch (flashlight), batteries, a first-aid box, bottled water, canned and dry food, a radio, matches or a lighter, a whistle, medicines, a blanket and some important documents.
b. We need them during emergencies and disasters such as earthquakes, floods, landslides, fires, storms or long power cuts.
c. We need them because in a disaster, shops, hospitals, electricity and water supply may stop working. The kit helps us survive for the first few days, treat minor injuries, stay informed and contact rescuers.
d. Yes, after the 2015 earthquake, my family prepared an emergency "go-bag" with water, dry food (chiura, biscuits), a torch, a radio, medicines and copies of our citizenship certificates.
About B (audio)
Exercise B is based on the audio recording about emergency kits, which is not printed in the textbook. Listen in class and choose the correct options. Listen carefully for the emergency the man mentions, the reason for a water filter, the kind of food to pack, Lisa's picture of an emergency shelter, the way to keep in touch with family, and the advice for families with small children.
C. Did you find this recording useful for you? Present your logic for or against the topic.
Answer: Yes, I found it very useful. Nepal is prone to earthquakes, floods and landslides, and the 2015 earthquake showed how unprepared most families were. The recording teaches what to keep in an emergency kit (clean water, a filter, light food that needs no cooking, first aid, a radio or two-way radio) and how to plan communication with the family. It also reminds parents to pack things that keep small children calm. Such simple preparation can save lives, so every family should prepare a kit and practise an emergency plan.
Speaking: Suggesting and Advising
Useful expressions
Advising: You should... • You ought to... • You'd better... • If I were you, I'd... • It'd be a good idea to...
Suggesting: Why don't you...? • How about / What about + -ing? • Let's... • Have you tried...?
Responding: That's a good idea. • Thanks, I'll try that. • I'm not sure that will work.
C. Suggestions to friends
| Situation | Suggestion |
|---|---|
| a. Your friend lost his/her pen. | Why don't you check your bag again? If you can't find it, you can borrow mine. |
| b. Ramila is weak in Mathematics. | You should practise a few problems every day. It'd be a good idea to join a study group or ask the teacher for help. |
| c. Pradip has a headache. | You'd better take some rest and drink plenty of water. If it continues, you should see a doctor. |
| d. Your friend is getting fat. | Why don't you start jogging in the morning? You ought to avoid junk food and sugary drinks. |
| e. Mukesh wants to dance but he can't. | If I were you, I'd join a dance class. How about watching some dance tutorials online and practising at home? |
D. Advice to Muna
| Muna says | Your advice |
|---|---|
| a. I'm hungry. | You should eat some fruit or a light snack. |
| b. I'm cold. | You'd better put on a warm jacket. |
| c. I can't control my temper. | You ought to take a deep breath and count to ten before you speak. Meditation might help too. |
| d. I have hiccups. | Why don't you drink a glass of water slowly or hold your breath for a few seconds? |
| e. I can't get to sleep at night. | If I were you, I'd stop using my phone an hour before bed and drink a glass of warm milk. |
Project Work
Interview some people in your locality. Ask them what kind of superstitions they grew up with and whether they believe in them now. Prepare a news article including their responses.
Sample news article
Old Beliefs Fading, But Not Gone: Locals Share Their Superstitions
By a Grade 11 student reporter
Many residents of our ward still remember the superstitions they grew up with, but most say they no longer follow them strictly, according to a survey carried out by Grade 11 students last week.
Sixty-eight-year-old Hari Bahadur Thapa, a retired farmer, said he grew up believing that a sneeze before a journey brought bad luck. "Even now I wait for a moment if someone sneezes," he laughed. "But I don't cancel my plans any more."
Housewife Sita Adhikari, 45, said she was taught never to sweep the house after dark, because it would "sweep away Laxmi". "I still follow it out of habit, but I know it has no scientific basis," she said.
Shopkeeper Ramesh Shrestha, 38, hangs lemons and green chillies at his shop door every Saturday. "It's a family tradition. My customers expect it," he said.
Younger people were more doubtful. College student Anisha Rai, 19, said she grew up hearing that cutting nails at night was unlucky. "I don't believe it now. Science has taught us to ask why," she said.
Of the fifteen people interviewed, only three said they fully believed in the superstitions they were taught, while most said they follow some of them only as harmless customs. All agreed that harmful practices such as accusing women of witchcraft must end.
Local teacher Bimala Karki said that education and awareness have changed people's attitudes. "Harmless customs are part of our culture, but blind belief should never harm anyone," she said.
Tip
Use the real names, ages and answers of the people you interview. A news article should have a headline, an opening paragraph that sums up the main finding, quotations from the people you met, and a closing comment.
More Class 11 English Notes
← Previous: Unit 7: Foresters without Diplomas
Next: Unit 9: Inauguration Speech →
All units and chapters: Class 11 English Guide (NEB) – Language Development and Literature