Table of Content

Shall There Be Peace? by Hermann Hesse: Class 11 English Unit 15 Questions and Answers | NEB

Class 11 English (NEB) · Section One: Language Development · Unit 15
Unit 15: War and Peace
Reading text: Shall There Be Peace? by Hermann Hesse

In this post, you will find complete answers to Unit 15: War and Peace from the Language Development section of the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook. It includes a summary of the reading text Shall There Be Peace?, answers to Before You Read, Ways with Words, Comprehension and Critical Thinking, model answers for Writing, Grammar rules with solved exercises, and guidance for Listening, Speaking and Project Work.

What this unit covers

Reading: Shall There Be Peace? (an essay by Hermann Hesse)

Vocabulary: word meanings; fill in the blanks

Writing: essays on war and peace; responsive youths

Grammar: sentence functions (subject, verb, object, complement, adverbial)

Listening: a news report on a protest

Speaking: encouraging and discouraging

Project: picture story book on war and peace

About the Text

"Shall There Be Peace?" is an essay by Hermann Hesse (1877–1962), the German-born Swiss novelist, poet and painter who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1946. He is famous for novels such as Siddhartha and Steppenwolf. Hesse wrote this essay near the end of the First World War (around Christmas 1917), when Russia had begun peace talks with Germany at Brest-Litovsk, while a huge, bloody battle was being prepared on the Western Front. He appeals to every ordinary person to take responsibility and work actively for peace.

Summary

Hesse begins by showing how leaders on all sides reject peace. Wilson (USA) and Lloyd George (Britain) declare they will fight until final victory. In the Italian parliament, the Socialist Mergari is treated like a madman for speaking a few natural, human words about peace. A German news agency (the Wolff dispatch) proudly denies any new German peace offer. Hesse says that whenever a "peaceful blade of grass" tries to grow, a military boot tramples it.

At the same time, peace talks have begun at Brest-Litovsk, where the German minister Kühlmann has quoted the Gospel's "peace on earth". If he means it, peace is inevitable, though Bible quotations from statesmen have rarely been sincere. The world watches two places: the peace talks in the east with hope, and the Western Front with dread, where the bloodiest, most ruthless battle of all time is about to begin.

Everyone except a few optimistic orators and war profiteers trembles at the thought. Hesse argues that the bigger and bloodier the battles, the less will be achieved: hatred and rivalry will grow, and the idea that political aims can be reached through war will survive. If one side wins totally, militarism wins. The humanitarian aims that leaders talk about cannot be achieved through mass slaughter.

He praises the Russians, who were the first nation to "attack the war at its root" and lay down their arms. It is the sacred duty of every person of good will not to be indifferent but to do their utmost to prevent the coming catastrophe. People say, "We have no power," and leaders also claim to be helpless, but the real blame lies in our own inertia, cowardice, laziness and reluctance to think. We rejoice in victories, mourn only our own losses, and silently accept war as an instrument of politics. Every politician wants disarmament and revolution, but only in the enemy camp.

Almost nobody wants the war except a small number of fanatics and profiteers, yet it continues because we tolerate it. "If we are in earnest, we can stop the war." We must stir ourselves, show our readiness for peace, stop useless provocations, accept small humiliations and concessions, and remove statesmen who ignore the cry of mankind. Peace is already present "as a thought, a desire... in every heart". If each person resolves to serve peace and clear away its obstacles, "then we shall have peace", and we will be free of our shared guilt.

Main message

  • War cannot achieve humanitarian aims; it only increases hatred, suffering and militarism.
  • Ordinary people share the guilt of war when they stay silent, indifferent or lazy.
  • Every individual has a duty to work actively for peace.
  • If people truly want peace and act together, wars can be stopped.

Before You Read

a. What is war?

Answer: War is an armed conflict between countries, or between groups within a country, in which soldiers and weapons are used to fight and kill, usually to gain land, power, resources or to defend beliefs. It causes massive loss of life and destruction.

b. What happens if there is war in a country? Describe its consequences.

Answer: War brings terrible consequences: loss of life of soldiers and innocent civilians; injury and disability; destruction of houses, schools, hospitals, roads and heritage; displacement, as people become refugees; economic collapse, with poverty, unemployment and hunger; disease and lack of medical care; psychological trauma, especially among children; and lasting hatred between communities. Development is pushed back by decades. Nepal's own armed conflict (1996–2006) killed over 13,000 people and left many families broken.

c. Describe a devastating war in world history.

Answer: The Second World War (1939–1945) was the most devastating war in history. It began when Germany under Adolf Hitler invaded Poland, and it spread across Europe, Asia and Africa. About 70 to 85 million people died, including about six million Jews killed in the Holocaust. Cities were bombed to ruins, and in August 1945 the USA dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in Japan, killing more than 200,000 people. After the war, the United Nations was founded in 1945 to prevent such a war from happening again.

Ways with Words

A. Match the words with their meanings

WordMeaning
a. proclaimv. declare
b. unswervingiv. steady or constant
c. magnanimousi. generous or forgiving
d. tramplex. crush
e. tremendousvii. huge
f. inevitableix. unavoidable
g. direiii. dreadful
h. anguishii. distress
i. impendingvi. upcoming
j. ruthlessviii. pitiless

B. Fill in the blanks

Answer
aThe soldiers suffer appalling injuries during the attack.
bShe is sanguine about prospects for the economic development of the country.
cInnocent people get unexpected slaughter in the war.
dThe crowd laughed at the absurdity of the singer's behaviour.
eThe intellectuals should be worried about the horror and futility of war.
fHe sensed her reluctance to continue the work.
gThey bestirred themselves at the first light of morning.

Comprehension

a. Why was the Italian Socialist Mergari treated like a madman?

Answer: Mergari was treated like a madman in the Italian Chamber because he had spoken "a few natural, human words" in favour of peace. At a time when leaders were determined to fight on until final victory, talking about peace was seen as foolish or unpatriotic.

b. Can political aims be attained by the criminal instrumentality of war? If yes, how?

Answer: According to Hesse, no. He calls war a "criminal instrumentality" and argues that the bigger and bloodier the battles, the less will be achieved for the future. War only deepens hatred and rivalry, and even a total victory would only mean the victory of militarism. The noble, humanitarian aims that statesmen talk about cannot be achieved through mass killing.

c. Which hopes and plans were said to be mutually contradictory?

Answer: The war aims of the leaders on both sides were mutually contradictory. They claimed to fight for humanitarian ideals, justice and lasting peace, yet they planned a massive, destructive battle that would increase hatred and make peace harder. Each side also hoped for its own final victory, which contradicts the other side's hopes. Hesse calls these "a jumble of hopeless fallacies".

d. What can be the sacred duty of every man of good will on earth?

Answer: The sacred duty of every man of good will is not to remain indifferent and let things take their course, but to do his utmost to prevent the final catastrophe of war, and to actively work for peace.

e. Is it good to tacitly accept war as an instrument of politics? If not, what else should be done?

Answer: No. Silently accepting war as a political tool makes us partly responsible for it. Instead, people should reject war openly, show their readiness for peace, stop provocative speeches, accept small concessions and humiliations for the sake of peace, remove leaders who ignore the cry of mankind, and settle disputes through dialogue and negotiation.

f. How can we stop war in the world?

Answer: Hesse says that "if we are in earnest, we can stop the war." We can stop war if each of us opens our heart to peace, firmly resolves to serve it, spreads thoughts of peace and works to remove the obstacles to it. We must overcome our laziness, cowardice and indifference, follow the example of nations that choose peace, and replace selfish, warmongering leaders.

g. What is the main message of this essay?

Answer: The main message is that war is senseless and achieves nothing good, and that every individual shares responsibility for it through indifference and silence. Peace is possible if ordinary people stop blaming leaders and actively commit themselves to the cause of peace.

Critical Thinking

a. Are warmongers the greatest enemies of peace? What do you want to suggest to them?

Answer: Yes, warmongers, people who encourage or profit from war, are among the greatest enemies of peace. They spread hatred, fear and nationalism, exaggerate threats, and push nations towards conflict for power, territory or profit from selling weapons. Hesse says they deserve "our contempt".

However, as Hesse also points out, the indifference of ordinary people helps warmongers succeed.

My suggestion to warmongers: Think about the mothers who lose their sons, the children who become orphans and the countries that are ruined. No victory is worth millions of lives. Real strength lies in solving problems through dialogue, cooperation and compromise. History remembers peace-makers like Gandhi and Mandela with respect, but remembers warmongers with shame. Use your power and resources to build schools and hospitals, not weapons.

b. John Steinbeck once said, "All war is a symptom of man's failure as a thinking animal." Do you agree? Why?

Answer: Yes, I agree. Human beings are called "thinking animals" because we have reason, language and the ability to solve problems through discussion. War happens when we stop thinking and allow anger, greed, pride and fear to control us. Instead of negotiating, compromising or using international law, we choose violence, which is the method of animals, not of rational beings.

Moreover, war never truly solves problems. It kills innocent people, destroys economies and leaves behind hatred that often leads to the next war. A thinking person can see that cooperation benefits everyone, while war harms both winners and losers. So every war is proof that humans have failed to use their greatest gift: reason. Organisations like the United Nations, and peaceful resolutions like Nepal's 2006 Comprehensive Peace Accord, show that thinking and dialogue can replace war.

c. Does any war end all wars and bring lasting peace to the world? Discuss.

Answer: No, history shows that no war has ended all wars. The First World War was called "the war to end all wars", but only twenty years later, the Second World War began, partly because of the anger and humiliation the first war left behind. After the Second World War came the Cold War and many regional wars in Korea, Vietnam, the Middle East, Africa, and more recently Ukraine and Gaza.

War creates winners and losers. The losers feel humiliated and want revenge, while the winners often become proud and aggressive. Wars also leave behind refugees, poverty and hatred, which become the seeds of new conflicts. As Hesse argues, a victory through war only strengthens militarism.

Lasting peace comes not from war but from justice, equality, education, dialogue, respect for human rights and cooperation among nations. Only when the causes of conflict are removed can peace last.

d. Why do you think countries go to war even though they have their own boundaries?

Answer: Countries go to war for many reasons even with fixed boundaries:

Greed for land and resources such as oil, minerals, water and fertile land.

Border disputes where boundaries are unclear or contested.

Power and domination: desire to become a regional or world power.

Ideological and religious differences.

Ethnic conflicts and nationalism.

Self-defence or fear of an enemy's growing power.

Political interests: some leaders start wars to distract people from problems at home or to stay in power.

The weapons industry: some profit from war.

Often, the real reasons are selfish interests, not the welfare of the people.

Writing

a. Write an essay on "War and Peace" in about 500 words.

Sample essay: War and Peace

War and peace are two opposite conditions of human society. War is an armed conflict between nations or groups, while peace is a state of harmony, security and freedom from violence. Throughout history, humanity has swung between these two states. Every war brings death and destruction, and every period of peace brings growth and prosperity. Yet, strangely, human beings continue to choose war again and again.

Wars have many causes: greed for land and resources, the desire for power, religious and ethnic hatred, border disputes and blind nationalism. Sometimes leaders start wars to serve their own political interests, and the weapons industry profits from them. But whatever the cause, the cost is always paid by ordinary people. Soldiers die on the battlefield, civilians are bombed in their homes, children become orphans, and millions become refugees. The First and Second World Wars together killed nearly a hundred million people. Hiroshima and Nagasaki showed that modern weapons can destroy entire cities in a moment. Today, nuclear weapons could wipe out humanity itself.

War also destroys the economy, schools, hospitals and cultural heritage, and leaves deep psychological wounds. Hatred created by war passes from one generation to the next, preparing the ground for new conflicts. As Hermann Hesse argued in "Shall There Be Peace?", the bigger and bloodier the war, the less it achieves. No war has ever truly ended all wars.

Peace, on the other hand, is the foundation of development. In peace, children go to school, farmers grow crops, businesses flourish and people enjoy their rights and freedom. Peace allows nations to spend money on education and health instead of weapons. Nepal's own experience shows this: after the 2006 Comprehensive Peace Accord ended the decade-long armed conflict, the country moved towards a new constitution, federalism and development.

However, peace does not mean only the absence of war. True peace requires justice, equality, respect for human rights and the removal of poverty and discrimination. Where people are oppressed, peace cannot last. Therefore, building peace is a continuous effort.

How can we achieve lasting peace? First, disputes should be solved through dialogue, negotiation and international law. Organisations like the United Nations must be strengthened. Second, education should teach tolerance, respect for diversity and non-violence. Third, nations should reduce weapons, especially nuclear weapons, and invest in human development. Finally, as Hesse said, every individual must take responsibility. Ordinary people should not remain silent; they should raise their voices against war and support leaders who work for peace.

In conclusion, war is a failure of humanity, while peace is its greatest achievement. Nepal, the birthplace of Lord Buddha, the "Light of Asia", has a special message for the world: peace begins in the mind. If each of us chooses peace in our hearts, homes and communities, we can build a world without war.

b. Write an essay on "Responsive Youths for Peace and Prosperity" in about 500 words.

Sample essay: Responsive Youths for Peace and Prosperity

Youth are the backbone of any nation. They are energetic, creative, courageous and full of new ideas. In Nepal, about 40 per cent of the population is young, which is a great opportunity for national development. If young people are responsive, that is, aware of their responsibilities and ready to act, they can become powerful agents of peace and prosperity.

History shows the power of youth. Young people played leading roles in Nepal's democratic movements of 1951, 1990 and 2006. Around the world, young activists like Malala Yousafzai and Greta Thunberg have raised their voices for education and the environment. However, youth energy can also be misused. During armed conflicts, many young people are recruited to fight, and frustrated, unemployed youths may turn to violence, crime or drugs. Therefore, it is important to guide youth in a positive direction.

For peace, responsive youths can promote tolerance, respect and harmony among people of different castes, religions, languages and regions. They can reject hate speech and fake news on social media, take part in peace campaigns, and help to resolve conflicts in their communities through dialogue. By practising non-violence and respecting others' opinions, they set an example for society.

For prosperity, young people can study hard, develop skills and become entrepreneurs who create jobs instead of only searching for them. Like the innovators at Mahabir Pun's National Innovation Centre, they can develop new products and technologies. They can modernise agriculture, promote tourism, and use information technology to start businesses. Even those working abroad can bring back skills, ideas and investment to Nepal.

Responsive youths should also be active citizens. They should vote wisely, raise their voices against corruption and injustice, and take part in social work such as cleanliness campaigns, blood donation, tree planting, disaster relief and literacy programmes. During the 2015 earthquake and the COVID-19 pandemic, thousands of young volunteers helped victims, showing the strength of responsive youth.

However, young people face many challenges, such as unemployment, lack of quality education, political misuse, drug abuse and brain drain. The government, family and society must support them by providing quality education, skills training, job opportunities, sports and a voice in decision-making.

In conclusion, youths are not only the leaders of tomorrow but also the change-makers of today. If they are responsible, disciplined and committed, they can make Nepal a peaceful and prosperous nation. As the saying goes, "The youth of a nation are the trustees of posterity."

Grammar: Sentence Functions

Quick rules

Subject (S): who or what does the action; usually before the verb. The fat man painted...

Verb (V): the action or state, including auxiliaries. ...will be reading...

Object (O): who or what receives the action (ask "what?/whom?" after the verb). Indirect object (Oi) = to whom; direct object (Od) = what. asked me (Oi) a question (Od)

Complement (C): describes or renames the subject (after be, become, seem) or the object. Bimala is a very beautiful girl (subject complement). They elected him President (object complement).

Adverbial (A): tells when, where, how, how often or how long. now, in Butwal, usually, last week

B. Divide the sentences into parts

Sentence partsPattern
aThe children (S) / are playing (V) / now (A).SVA
bSrijana (S) / will be reading (V) / a story (O).SVO
cBimala (S) / is (V) / a very beautiful girl (C).SVC
dShe (S) / usually (A) / wears (V) / glasses (O).SAVO
eThey (S) / elected (V) / him (O) / President (C).SVOC
fRabin (S) / is laughing (V).SV
gHe (S) / has (V) / a big house (O) / in Butwal (A).SVOA
hThe man who lives next door (S) / is (V) / a professor (C).SVC
iHer uncle (S) / has been living (V) / in Kathmandu (A) / for fifteen years (A).SVAA
jThe girl with long hair (S) / asked (V) / me (Oi) / a question (Od) / last week (A).SVOOA

Note

In (h) and (j), the whole noun phrase is the subject, including the relative clause "who lives next door" and the phrase "with long hair". In (g), "in Butwal" can also be seen as part of the object phrase "a big house in Butwal".

Listening

A. Look at the picture and answer these questions.

Answer: a. They seem to be protesters, ordinary local people holding placards and banners.

b. They have gathered to protest against a decision that affects them, perhaps a government plan to build a new road, factory or airport in their area, which may destroy their homes, land or environment.

About B and C (audio)

Exercises B and C are based on the audio news report, which is not printed in the textbook. Listen in class and note: who Chris is, which day of the protest it is, what the people oppose (the new road plan), whether police made arrests, whether construction has begun, where the reporter is, why people prefer a railway to a highway, and on what condition they will stop protesting.

D. Have you seen or experienced any event of protest? Discuss.

Answer: Yes. Last year, I saw a peaceful protest in our town when the municipality planned to cut down the old trees along the main road to widen it. Local residents, students and environmental groups gathered with placards saying "Save Our Trees" and "Development Without Destruction". They sat on the road for two days and submitted a memorandum to the mayor. The protest was peaceful, and finally the municipality agreed to change the design and plant new trees. I learned that peaceful protest is a democratic right and can bring positive change when people unite for a good cause. However, protests should not damage public property or harm others.

Speaking: Encouraging and Discouraging

Useful expressions

Encouraging: Come on! • Go on! • Keep it up! • You can do it! • Well done! • You're doing great! • That's a good idea. • Don't give up!

Discouraging: Don't bother with it. • Don't waste your time. • It's not worth the effort. • Why do you want to do that? • It's not a good idea. • I wouldn't do that if I were you.

B. How useful are these experiences for students?

Ritu: I'm thinking of working part-time at a café after school.

Sagar: That's a good idea! You'll learn responsibility and earn some money too.

Ritu: And I want to learn about money management.

Sagar: Go on! Knowing how to save and spend wisely will help you all your life.

Ritu: What about volunteer work? Is it useful?

Sagar: Definitely! It teaches teamwork and kindness. Keep it up!

Ritu: My cousin says I should choose my specialisation just because it pays well.

Sagar: I wouldn't do that if I were you. Choose the subject you enjoy and are good at.

Ritu: And making a circle of friends?

Sagar: That's important too. Good friends support you. But don't waste your time with people who pull you down.

C. Role-plays

a. Your best friend did poorly on a test

You: Hey, why do you look so sad?

Friend: I failed my maths test. I don't think I can ever do maths.

You: Come on! One bad test doesn't decide your future. You can do it!

Friend: But I studied so hard.

You: Then let's find out what went wrong. We can practise together every evening. Don't give up!

Friend: Thanks. That really helps.

b. Teaching your sister to play tennis

Sister: I keep hitting the ball into the net!

You: That's all right. Keep your eye on the ball and swing a little higher.

Sister: Like this?

You: Well done! That was a great shot. You're doing very well. Keep it up!

c. A friend thinking of taking driving lessons

Friend: I'm thinking of taking driving lessons, but I'm scared.

You: Go on! It's a very useful skill, and the instructors are patient.

Friend: My brother says it's not worth the effort because the traffic is terrible.

You: Don't listen to him. Start slowly on quiet roads. You'll be fine!

Project Work

Search for photos that show the devastating effects of war and photos that show the effects of peace. Make a picture story book with captions.

Sample captions for your picture story book

PagePicture ideaCaption
1A city destroyed by bombingWar turns homes into rubble in minutes.
2Refugee families walking with bagsMillions lose everything and become strangers in other lands.
3A crying child in a ruined streetChildren pay the highest price for wars they never started.
4Wounded soldiers / a hospitalEvery bullet leaves a wound, on the body and in the heart.
5A graveyard with rows of crossesNo victory can bring back the dead.
6Children going to school happilyIn peace, children carry books, not guns.
7Farmers harvesting cropsPeace lets the fields grow food instead of graves.
8People of different cultures celebrating togetherPeace means living together in harmony.
9Leaders shaking hands / signing a peace accordDialogue builds what war destroys.
10Lumbini, the birthplace of BuddhaPeace begins in the mind of every person.

Tip

Arrange the pages as a story: start with the horrors of war, show the turning point (peace talks), and end with the blessings of peace. Write the sources of the photos at the back of the book.

More Class 11 English Notes

Post a Comment