Unit 16: Critical Thinking
Reading text: What Is the Soul? by Bertrand Russell
In this post, you will find complete answers to Unit 16: Critical Thinking from the Language Development section of the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook. It includes a summary of the reading text What Is the Soul?, answers to Before You Read, Ways with Words, Comprehension and Critical Thinking, model answers for Writing, Grammar rules with solved exercises, and guidance for Listening, Speaking and Project Work.
What this unit covers
Reading: What Is the Soul? (an essay by Bertrand Russell)
Vocabulary: crossword; word meanings
Writing: critical essays on the existence of God and religion and morality
Grammar: used to (past habits)
Listening: Jessica talks about her father
Speaking: comparing past and present habits
Project: review of "Is the Soul Immortal?" by Swami Vivekananda
About the Text
"What Is the Soul?" is a philosophical essay by Bertrand Russell (1872–1970), the British philosopher, mathematician and social critic who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1950. Using the discoveries of modern physics and psychology, Russell questions the old belief that a person is made of a body and an immortal soul. He argues that neither mind nor matter is a permanent "thing": both are only convenient ways of grouping events. Therefore, there is no reason to believe that the soul or memory survives death.
Summary
Russell says that every new advance in science makes us realise that we know less than we thought. When he was young, everyone believed that a man consists of a soul and a body: the body exists in time and space, the soul only in time. People argued about whether the soul survives death, but nobody doubted that it existed. Science was comfortably materialistic.
Now these "fine old simplicities" are lost. Physicists say there is no such thing as matter, and psychologists say there is no such thing as mind. This is as strange as a cobbler saying there are no boots, or a tailor saying all men are naked. Some psychologists try to reduce mental activity to bodily activity, but physics shows that the "body" itself is only an elaborate scientific construction. So we go round in a circle: mind comes from the body, and the body is an invention of the mind. There must be something that is neither mind nor body, from which both arise.
The plain man believes that anything you can bump into must be real. But physics shows that you never really touch anything: the electrons and protons of your hand are attracted and repelled by those of the object, and a disturbance travels along your nerves to the brain, producing the sensation of contact, which can even be deceptive. And electrons and protons themselves are only rough ways of grouping waves or probabilities. Matter has become "too ghostly" to be used as "a stick with which to beat the mind".
However, science gives no evidence of a soul either. Mind and matter were like the lion and the unicorn fighting for the crown; in the end, both turn out to be imaginary symbols. The world consists of events. When events are grouped by one kind of causal relation, we call the group a physical object; grouped by another kind, we call it a mind. An event in a person's head belongs to both his brain and his mind.
So there is no reason to suppose that mind or matter is immortal. The essence of mind is memory, and memory depends on brain structure, which decays at death, so memory must end too. Opponents of materialism wanted to prove that the mind is immortal and that the ultimate power in the universe is mental, but on both points the materialists were right. Human wishes have power only on the earth's surface, and even that depends on the sun. According to the second law of thermodynamics, the human race cannot continue forever. This may seem gloomy, but what happens millions of years from now does not much concern us. Science reduces our cosmic pride but greatly increases our comfort on earth, which is why it has been tolerated despite the horror of theologians.
Main message
- Modern science has destroyed the simple belief in a separate soul and body.
- Both mind and matter are ways of organising events, not permanent substances.
- Since memory depends on the brain, there is no reason to believe the soul or mind survives death.
- Science reduces human pride about our place in the universe but improves our life on earth.
Before You Read
a. Which one do you think is primary: body or soul? Why?
Answer: Opinions differ. Many religious and spiritual traditions, including Hinduism and Buddhism, consider the soul primary: the body is temporary, like clothes, while the soul (atma) is eternal and gives life to the body. From a scientific point of view, the body is primary, because thinking, feeling and memory depend on the brain; without a living body, we cannot observe any mind.
In my view, both are important and closely connected. A healthy body supports a healthy mind, and a positive mind keeps the body healthy. Without the body, the "soul" cannot act in this world, and without the mind or spirit, the body is only a machine.
b. "A circle has no beginning." Do you agree or disagree with the statement? Explain.
Answer: I agree. A circle is a closed curve in which every point is the same distance from the centre, so there is no starting or ending point; we can begin at any point and come back to it. In philosophy, the statement describes ideas that depend on each other endlessly, like "Which came first, the chicken or the egg?" Russell uses this idea when he says we go "round and round in a circle": mind comes from the body, and the body is an invention of the mind. Many traditions also see life as a circle of birth, death and rebirth.
Ways with Words
A. Crossword puzzle
| Clue | Meaning | Answer |
|---|---|---|
| Across 3 | emergence or origination | emanation |
| Across 5 | impossible to achieve or overcome | insuperable |
| Across 7 | appropriate or suitable | adequate |
| Across 8 | force back | repel |
| Across 10 | up to now | hitherto |
| Down 1 | unquestionable, impossible to doubt | indubitable |
| Down 2 | never done or known before | unprecedented |
| Down 4 | obviously or clearly | evidently |
| Down 6 | moved with a violent, irregular action | agitated |
| Down 9 | conservative | orthodox |
B. Find the words from the text
| Meaning | Word |
|---|---|
| a. misleading or illusory | deceptive |
| b. in a natural state; not yet processed or refined | crude |
| c. a mythical horse-like animal with a single horn on its forehead | unicorn |
| d. never dying or decaying | immortal |
| e. come to an end; stop | cease |
| f. to activate or put into motion | actuate |
Comprehension
a. What's the difference between the body and the soul?
Answer: According to the traditional belief described by Russell, the body exists in both time and space: it is physical, can be seen and touched, and decays at death. The soul exists in time only, not in space: it is non-physical, and many people believe it survives death.
b. What do you understand by the psychologists' saying that there is no such thing as mind?
Answer: Some psychologists try to reduce all mental activity to physical activity of the body, such as the brain, nerves and muscles. For them, thinking, feeling and remembering are only processes of the body, so there is no separate thing called "mind".
c. How can mental activity be reduced to physical activity?
Answer: Mental activity can be reduced to physical activity by explaining thoughts, feelings and sensations as processes in the brain and nervous system. For example, when we touch something, electrons and protons in our body are disturbed, and this disturbance travels along the nerves to the brain, producing the sensation of contact. In the same way, memory depends on a certain brain structure. However, Russell says there are still difficulties in doing this completely.
d. How are mind and body related?
Answer: According to Russell, mind and body are related in a circle: the mind seems to be an emanation of the body, while the body is a concept invented by the mind. In fact, both are ways of grouping events. Events grouped by one kind of causal relation form a physical object (like the brain); grouped by another kind, they form a mind. An event in a person's head belongs to both.
e. What is the relation between mind and memory? Does memory survive a person's death?
Answer: Memory is the most essential characteristic of the mind. But memory is clearly connected with a certain kind of brain structure. Since the brain decays at death, there is every reason to suppose that memory also ceases. So, according to Russell, memory does not survive a person's death.
f. How is our power on the earth's surface entirely dependent upon the sun?
Answer: All our power on earth, such as growing food, using energy and changing the land, depends on the sun's light and heat. Plants grow through sunlight, which gives us food; the sun drives the weather, the water cycle and almost all our energy sources. If the sun grew cold, we could hardly realise any of our wishes, and life itself would end.
Critical Thinking
a. Do you believe that the soul really exists? Write your arguments in support of your answer.
Answer: Answer (one point of view): I believe that the soul exists, though it cannot be proved by science.
First, human beings have qualities like consciousness, conscience, love and a sense of right and wrong, which are difficult to explain as only chemical activity in the brain. Second, almost all cultures and religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism, Christianity and Islam, believe in a soul; such a universal belief suggests a deep human experience. The Bhagavad Gita says the soul is never born and never dies; it only changes bodies like clothes. Third, many people report experiences such as near-death experiences, intuition and deep meditation that point beyond the body.
On the other hand, scientists like Russell argue that there is no evidence of a soul, and that memory and personality depend on the brain, which dies. This is a strong argument, because science accepts only what can be tested.
In my view, science explains how the body and brain work, but it may not yet explain everything about human consciousness. Belief in the soul gives life meaning, moral responsibility and hope. So I believe in the soul, while respecting the scientific view.
(You may also argue the opposite side, using Russell's reasons: no scientific evidence, memory depends on the brain, and mind and matter are only ways of organising events.)
b. If you want to change your body, you first have to change your mind. Discuss.
Answer: I agree with this statement. Every action of the body begins with a decision of the mind. If someone wants to lose weight, become fit or give up smoking, they must first decide firmly, believe they can do it, and develop discipline. Without a change in thinking, people start exercise or a diet with excitement but give up after a few days.
A positive mindset creates motivation and habits: waking up early, eating healthy food, exercising regularly. Mental strength helps us overcome laziness, temptation and pain. Doctors also know that stress, anxiety and negative thinking can cause disease, while a calm and hopeful mind helps the body heal faster. Practices like yoga and meditation work on both mind and body together.
Of course, the body also affects the mind: exercise and good sleep improve mood. So mind and body are connected, but real and lasting change in the body begins in the mind. As the saying goes, "The body achieves what the mind believes."
Writing
a. Write critically on "The Existence of God".
Sample essay: The Existence of God
The question of whether God exists is one of the oldest and most important questions in human thought. Believers, sceptics and philosophers have debated it for thousands of years, and it still has no answer that satisfies everyone.
Arguments for God: Believers point to the order and design of the universe: the movement of the planets, the balance of nature and the complexity of the human body seem to suggest an intelligent creator. Another argument is that everything has a cause, so there must be a first cause that started everything, which they call God. Many people also speak of personal experiences of God through prayer, meditation or miracles, and argue that our sense of morality, of right and wrong, comes from a divine source. For billions of people, faith in God gives comfort, hope and meaning, especially in times of suffering.
Arguments against God: Sceptics and scientists argue that there is no scientific evidence for God. The universe and life can be explained by natural processes, such as the Big Bang and evolution. They ask: if God is all-powerful and good, why is there so much suffering, disease and injustice in the world? They also point out that different religions describe God in very different ways, which suggests that God is a human idea. Thinkers like Bertrand Russell argued that belief should be based on evidence, not on fear or tradition.
My view: The existence of God cannot be proved or disproved by science, because science studies only the physical world. It is ultimately a matter of faith and personal experience. What matters most is not whether we believe or not, but how we live. A believer who spreads hatred in God's name does more harm than an atheist who lives honestly and kindly. Whether we believe in God or not, we should respect each other's beliefs and practise love, truth and compassion.
b. Write critically on "Religion influences ethics and morality".
Sample essay: Religion Influences Ethics and Morality
Ethics and morality are principles of right and wrong that guide human behaviour. For thousands of years, religion has been one of the strongest sources of these principles. Most religions teach values such as truth, non-violence, compassion, honesty, charity and respect for parents and elders.
Positive influence: Religious teachings give clear moral rules. Hinduism teaches dharma (duty) and karma (the idea that good actions bring good results). Buddhism teaches the Five Precepts, including not killing, not stealing and not lying. Christianity teaches "Love your neighbour as yourself", and Islam stresses charity (zakat) and justice. Belief in reward and punishment after death encourages many people to do good and avoid evil. Religious communities run schools, hospitals and charities, and festivals strengthen family and social bonds.
Negative influence: However, religion has also been misused. In the name of religion, people have fought wars, practised discrimination and supported harmful customs such as untouchability, sati, chhaupadi and witchcraft accusations. Blind faith can stop people from thinking critically. Sometimes people follow religious rituals but behave dishonestly in daily life.
Critical view: Religion is an important influence, but it is not the only source of morality. Many non-religious people are deeply ethical, guided by reason, empathy, law and human rights. Morality also comes from family, education, culture and conscience. The best approach is to keep the universal moral values that religions share (truth, kindness and justice) and to reject practices that harm or divide people. In this way, religion can remain a positive force for ethics in modern society.
Grammar: Used To
Quick rules
used to + base verb = a past habit or state that is no longer true: I used to live in a flat. (I don't now.)
Negative: didn't use to (not "didn't used to"): I didn't use to like coffee. Also: I never used to...
Question: Did + subject + use to...? Did you use to play football?
Don't confuse with be used to + -ing = be accustomed to: I'm used to getting up early.
A. Rewrite using used to
| Answer | |
|---|---|
| a | I used to live in a flat when I was a child. |
| b | She used to love eating chocolate, but now she hates it. |
| c | Did he use to go fishing in the summer? |
| d | My sister used to play tennis when she was at school. |
| e | Did he use to play football every weekend? |
| f | My grandfather used to speak five languages. |
| g | I didn't use to hate school in the beginning. |
| h | Did you use to live in Kathmandu? |
| i | He used to play dandibiyo when he was a small child. |
| j | She used to wear a frock when she was small, but nowadays she wears jeans. |
B. A paragraph about your past habits
When I was a small child, I used to live with my grandparents in a village in Syangja. I used to wake up with the crowing of the rooster and help my grandmother feed the goats. I used to walk to school with my friends along a narrow path through the fields. After school, we used to play dandibiyo, marbles and hide-and-seek until it got dark. I didn't use to watch much television because there was no electricity in our village at that time. Instead, my grandfather used to tell us stories of kings and ghosts by the fire. Now I live in the city, spend more time on my phone and hardly play outside, but I still miss those simple and happy days.
Listening
A. Look at the picture and answer these questions.
Answer: a. The people seem to be sailing a boat on the sea and enjoying the sea breeze, or relaxing and playing on the beach.
b. Around the sea, I like the sound of the waves, the cool breeze, walking on the sandy beach, collecting shells, watching the sunset over the water, and seeing boats and seabirds.
About B and C (audio)
Exercises B and C are based on the audio recording of Jessica speaking about her father, which is not printed in the textbook. Listen in class and note: whom she is talking about, how old she was in her first memory of him, what he loved, where he worked, who spoke before her, how she feels about the ocean, where her father was happiest, and what they are publishing this year.
D. Do you have any special hobbies and interests? Discuss.
Answer: Yes. My favourite hobby is photography. I take pictures of nature, festivals and people's daily lives with my mobile phone, and I share them on a small photo page. It helps me notice beauty in ordinary things. I also enjoy reading novels, especially adventure and mystery stories, and playing the flute, which I learned from my uncle. On weekends I play football with friends. These hobbies relax my mind after study, and photography may even become my career one day.
Speaking: Comparing Past and Present Habits
Useful expressions
Past: I used to... • I didn't use to... • When I was a child, I would... • Did you use to...?
Present: Nowadays I... • These days I... • Now I... • I no longer... • I don't... any more.
B. Sample questions and answers
| Action | Question | Answer |
|---|---|---|
| swimming | Did you use to swim when you were small? | Yes, I used to swim in the river every summer, but nowadays I rarely swim. |
| playing the guitar | Did you use to play the guitar? | No, I didn't use to, but now I'm learning it. |
| visiting relatives | Did you use to visit your relatives often? | Yes, we used to visit them every Saturday. These days we only meet during Dashain and Tihar. |
| going fishing | Did you use to go fishing? | Yes, my father used to take me fishing, but now I don't have time. |
| playing kapardi | Did you use to play kapardi (cowrie shells)? | Yes, we used to play kapardi during Tihar. Now we play games on our phones. |
| drawing pictures | Did you use to draw pictures? | Yes, I used to draw a lot. I still draw sometimes. |
| listening to music | Did you use to listen to music? | I used to listen to the radio. Now I listen on my phone with earphones. |
| having long hair | Did you use to have long hair? | Yes, I used to have long hair, but now it's short. |
| going to the cinema | Did you use to go to the cinema? | Rarely. Now I watch films online. |
| sleeping earlier | Did you use to sleep earlier? | Yes, I used to sleep by 8 p.m. Nowadays I sleep after 11. |
C. Talk about past and present lifestyles of people in your society.
Answer: In the past, most people in our society used to live in joint families and work on farms. They used to walk long distances because there were few roads and vehicles. People used to cook on firewood, fetch water from springs and wear homemade clothes. Entertainment meant festivals, folk songs and community gatherings. Letters were the main way to communicate with people far away.
Nowadays, many families are nuclear, and many young people work in cities or abroad. We travel by bus and motorbike, cook on gas stoves and buy ready-made clothes. Mobile phones and the internet connect us instantly, and we watch films and use social media. Life has become more comfortable and faster, but people have less time for each other, and there is more stress and pollution.
Project Work
Find the essay "Is the Soul Immortal?" by Swami Vivekananda from online sources. Critically review it, write its summary and present it to the class.
Sample summary and review
About the writer: Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902) was an Indian Hindu monk and philosopher, a disciple of Ramakrishna, who introduced Vedanta and Yoga to the Western world. He is famous for his speech at the World's Parliament of Religions in Chicago in 1893.
Summary: In this essay, Vivekananda takes up the question that has troubled humans in every age: does the soul survive death? He argues that whatever is made of parts (compound) must one day break apart and die. The body is a compound of material elements, so it decays. But the soul is simple, not made of parts, so it cannot be destroyed. He also argues that nothing comes from nothing: if the soul had a beginning, it would also have an end, so the soul has always existed and will always exist. Our present life is the result of past existence, and we carry the impressions of past lives. According to Vedanta, the real Self (Atman) is pure, eternal and infinite; it is neither born nor dies. Death is only a change of body, like changing clothes.
Critical review: Vivekananda's essay is logical and inspiring, and it gives hope and moral strength by teaching that the real self is beyond death. His reasoning about compounds and simplicity is clever. However, his arguments are based on philosophical reasoning and faith, not on scientific evidence. Thinkers like Bertrand Russell argue the opposite: that the mind depends on the brain and ends with it. Comparing the two essays shows how philosophy, religion and science look at the same question in different ways. The essay is worth reading for anyone interested in the meaning of life.
Tip
Read the original essay yourself before presenting, and quote one or two of its key lines. Compare Vivekananda's view with Russell's, and end with your own opinion.
More Class 11 English Notes
← Previous: Unit 15: Shall There Be Peace?
Next: Unit 17: What Lost Identity? The Diaspora and Globalisation →
All units and chapters: Class 11 English Guide (NEB) – Language Development and Literature