Scientific Research Is a Token of Humankind's Survival
by Vladimir Keilis-Borok
In this post, you will find complete notes on the essay Scientific Research Is a Token of Humankind's Survival by Vladimir Keilis-Borok from the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook: the author's introduction, a summary, the main ideas, and answers to all the textbook questions, including an essay on whether science is a blessing or a curse.
About the Author
Vladimir Keilis-Borok (1921–2013) was a Russian mathematical geophysicist and seismologist, a scientist who studies earthquakes. He taught at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), and led a research group at the International Institute for Earthquake Prediction Theory and Mathematical Geophysics of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
He was also co-director and founder of the research programme on non-linear dynamics and earthquake prediction at the Abdus Salam International Centre for Theoretical Physics in Trieste, Italy. He is known for pioneering methods of earthquake prediction and for his role in the scientific talks that led to the nuclear test ban.
Introduction to the Essay
In "Scientific Research Is a Token of Humankind's Survival", Keilis-Borok explains why people choose to become scientists despite earning less than businessmen, lawyers and doctors. Through his own experience during the Cold War, when his research on seismic waves helped make a nuclear test ban possible, he shows that science is not just abstract theory but humankind's "indispensable guardian and caretaker". The essay argues that basic scientific research is essential for solving the world's problems and ensuring our survival.
Summary
The essay opens with a popular saying: "If you are so clever, why are you so poor?" Why do people become scientists when businessmen, lawyers and doctors earn much more? The writer answers with Tolstoy's idea that a writer is someone who cannot live without writing; the same is true of a scientist. Science is an exciting adventure whose main reward is discovery itself. Instead of big money, scientists get freedom, camaraderie and independence, and the thrill of uncovering nature's mysteries.
In 1960, at the height of the Cold War, the writer was in Moscow researching the theory of seismic waves, enjoying the mathematical challenge without thinking about its practical use. Suddenly the President of the Soviet Academy of Sciences summoned him: an American scientist, Frank Press, had quoted his work during secret talks in Geneva between experts from the three nuclear powers (the USSR, USA and UK). To his surprise, he was sent to Geneva.
At that time the world lived under the threat of nuclear annihilation. Each superpower could destroy the other, and the other could retaliate within minutes. This "Mutually Assured Destruction" (MAD) was the only thin thread protecting humanity. Continued nuclear tests meant ever stronger bombs, so the powers wanted to agree to ban nuclear tests. The problem was: if one country secretly carried out an underground nuclear explosion, how could the others detect it?
Underground explosions produce earth tremors similar to earthquakes, so the problem was directly connected with the theory of seismic waves. Suddenly, the writer's theoretical knowledge was linked to the survival of humankind. Despite Cold War tensions, scientists from both sides of the Iron Curtain found a common language: respect for hard evidence, ranking by expertise only, and persistent self-criticism. Their solution helped politicians reach the historic decision of a nuclear test ban. The episode taught him that scientists everywhere think alike, that he need never feel lonely abroad, and that "while there is science, there is hope of survival and well-being for all of us."
People often think scientists lack practical sense; a great mathematician once left home in shoes from two different pairs. But scientists are actually the most practical people in the world, because all new technologies grow out of fundamental research: antibiotics, electronics, biotechnology, synthetic fibres, the green revolution and genetic forensics. Only basic research can give new energy sources, minerals, defence against terrorism, a cure for cancer and new transport. Training in basic science gives a head start in any career.
Today civilisation is threatened by natural and man-made disasters: earthquakes, destruction of megacities, environmental catastrophes, economic and social crises, release of radioactivity and mass violence. Trillions of dollars are spent on them, yet dangers grow. The solution depends not on money but on intellectual resources; only basic research can create a disaster-preparedness industry. Scientific research is "an exciting venture into the great unknown and the token of humankind's survival." Finally, the writer reminds us that human qualities are more important than science, but "if humanly used, science is their indispensable guardian and caretaker."
Main Ideas of the Essay
- Scientists choose science out of passion; their reward is discovery, freedom, independence and camaraderie, not money.
- Even abstract research can suddenly become vital for humanity, as seismic-wave theory did for the nuclear test ban.
- Science creates a common language that unites people across political and cultural divides.
- Scientists are the most practical people, because all modern technologies come from basic research.
- Intellectual resources, not money, are the key to preventing disasters.
- Science, used humanely, is the guardian of human survival and well-being.
Before Reading
a. What is science? What do the scientists do?
Answer: Science is the systematic study of the natural and physical world through observation, experiment and reasoning, to discover facts and laws. Scientists ask questions about nature, form hypotheses, carry out experiments, collect and analyse data, and draw conclusions. They make discoveries and inventions that increase human knowledge and solve practical problems in health, agriculture, energy, communication and the environment.
b. We are all scientists. Share your scientific experiences that you have got in your everyday life.
Answer: In everyday life, we often think like scientists. For example, when my mobile phone stopped charging, I tested different chargers and sockets to find out whether the problem was the cable, the socket or the phone; that is experimenting and eliminating possibilities. While cooking, I learned that rice cooks faster in a pressure cooker because higher pressure raises the boiling point of water. I noticed that milk boils over but water does not, and later learned it is because of the proteins and fat in milk. Observing, guessing, testing and concluding are the steps of the scientific method.
c. Complete the table.
Answer: A completed version of the table:
| Professional | Vocation | Field | Reward |
|---|---|---|---|
| Writer | writing | Literature | fame, satisfaction of creation |
| Lawyer | arguing | Law | money (fees), justice |
| Teacher | teaching | Education | respect, satisfaction of shaping lives |
| Scientist | researching, discovering | Science | freedom (and the joy of discovery) |
Understanding the Text
a. What does a scientist get instead of big money?
Answer: Instead of big money, a scientist gets freedom, camaraderie (friendship with like-minded colleagues) and independence. Honours and promotions depend more on their own work, and they enjoy the overwhelming feeling of uncovering nature's mysteries. The main reward is discovery itself.
b. What was the problem that the nuclear powers had faced?
Answer: The nuclear powers wanted to sign an agreement to stop testing nuclear weapons. The problem was: if one country secretly violated the agreement by carrying out an underground nuclear explosion, how could the other countries detect it? Underground explosions produce tremors similar to natural earthquakes, so it was difficult to tell them apart.
c. In which area did Keilis-Borok's theoretical knowledge have a direct application?
Answer: His theoretical knowledge of seismic waves had a direct application in detecting underground nuclear explosions, distinguishing them from natural earthquakes. This was directly linked to the survival of humankind, because it made a nuclear test ban possible.
d. What was the important decision that the politicians took after the Geneva talks?
Answer: Using the scientists' solution, the politicians reached one of the most important decisions of their time: a nuclear test ban, an agreement to stop testing nuclear weapons.
e. What are the natural and man-made disasters mentioned by the author?
Answer: The author mentions earthquakes (natural), the self-inflicted destruction of megacities, environmental catastrophes, economic and social crises, a massive release of radioactivity from nuclear waste, an earthquake in the middle of a megalopolis, outbursts of mass violence, terrorism, and wars in "hot" regions.
Reference to the Context
a. The professional addressed as "you" in "If you are so clever, why are you so poor?" refers to a... (i) lawyer (ii) doctor (iii) scientist (iv) businessman. Justify your choice.
Answer: The answer is (iii) scientist. The writer uses this popular expression to introduce the question of why some people become scientists even though businessmen, lawyers and doctors earn much more. Scientists are considered very clever, but they are not rich, which is exactly what the question mocks. The writer then explains that scientists are rewarded not with money but with discovery, freedom and independence.
b. The writer says, "I found myself in Geneva." What does it express?
Answer: The expression shows the writer's surprise. He was quietly doing theoretical research on seismic waves in Moscow, without thinking about its practical use. Suddenly, because an American scientist had quoted his work, he was sent to Geneva to take part in top-secret talks between the nuclear powers. It happened so unexpectedly that he felt as if he had been carried there without planning it. It also shows how pure research can suddenly become important for world affairs.
c. Are the following statements true? Why or why not?
Answer: i. Money is more powerful than intellectual resources. False, according to the essay. Trillions of dollars are spent on disasters, yet the dangers keep growing. The writer says the hope for breaking this stalemate rests not on money but on intellectual resources, even though money is more popular.
ii. Intellectual resources help the survival of mankind. True. Scientific knowledge solved the problem of detecting nuclear tests and made the test ban possible. Basic research also gives us medicines, new energy and disaster preparedness.
iii. Basic research is a way of stalling disasters. True. The writer says only basic research can create a springboard for a new disaster-preparedness industry, for example by predicting earthquakes and managing environmental and social crises.
d. How does the essayist justify that scientific research is the token of humankind's survival?
Answer: The essayist justifies this in several ways. First, through his personal experience: his research on seismic waves helped scientists find a way to detect secret underground nuclear tests, which allowed the nuclear test ban and reduced the threat of nuclear destruction during the Cold War.
Second, he shows that all modern technologies that improve and protect life, such as antibiotics, electronics, biotechnology and the green revolution, come from basic research. Third, he argues that civilisation is threatened by growing natural and man-made disasters, and that money alone cannot stop them; only intellectual resources and basic research can create ways to prepare for and prevent them. Finally, science unites people across political divides with a common language. Therefore, while there is science, there is hope of survival.
e. What can be the purpose of the essayist in using quotations in the essay?
Answer: The essayist uses quotations from Tolstoy, Frank Press, McGeorge Bundy, a popular expression and a French proverb to support and strengthen his arguments with the authority of well-known people, to make the essay interesting and memorable, and to introduce or sum up ideas. For example, Tolstoy's idea explains why scientists choose science; the popular expression "If you are so clever, why are you so poor?" opens the topic; and the French proverb supports his point that wisdom matters more than wealth.
f. Discuss and illustrate the writer's stand that scientists are the most practical people in the world.
Answer: People often think scientists are absent-minded and impractical, like the great mathematician who left home wearing shoes from two different pairs. But the writer argues that scientists are actually the most practical people, because all new technologies and industries grow out of their fundamental research.
He gives examples: antibiotics, electronics, biotechnology, synthetic fibres, the green revolution and genetic forensic diagnosis all came from basic science. Only research can give us new energy sources, new mineral deposits, defence against terrorism, a cure for cancer and new forms of transport. People trained in theoretical physics are hired by financial institutions, and biologists become founders of pharmaceutical companies. His own theoretical work on seismic waves helped stop nuclear tests. So scientists' work has the most practical results of all.
Reference Beyond the Text
a. Everyone lives under the fear of annihilation by nuclear weapons. Explain this statement.
Answer: This statement means that the existence of nuclear weapons puts the whole of humanity at risk of complete destruction. During the Cold War, the USA and the USSR had enough nuclear bombs to destroy each other many times over. If one attacked, the other would retaliate within minutes: "Mutually Assured Destruction". A single mistake or misunderstanding could have ended human civilisation.
Even today, several countries possess thousands of nuclear weapons. Wars and tensions between nuclear powers, the risk of terrorists getting nuclear material, and accidents at nuclear plants (like Chernobyl and Fukushima) keep this fear alive. Nuclear war would not only kill millions instantly but also cause radiation, disease and a "nuclear winter" that could destroy life on Earth. That is why nuclear disarmament and test bans are vital for humanity.
b. The essayist says "While there is science, there is hope of survival and well-being for all of us." Explain it.
Answer: The essayist means that science is humanity's best tool for solving problems and protecting life. His own experience showed that science could reduce the danger of nuclear war by making a test ban possible. Science also gives us medicines and vaccines to fight diseases, technology to grow more food, ways to predict and prepare for disasters, and new sources of energy. Moreover, science gives people from different countries a common language based on evidence and reason, which can bring them together. As long as humans continue scientific research and use it humanely, there is hope of overcoming the dangers we face.
c. Is science a blessing or a curse? Write an essay on it.
Sample essay: Science: A Blessing or a Curse?
We live in an age of science. From the moment we wake up to the alarm on our mobile phone until we switch off the light at night, science shapes every part of our lives. Yet the same science that saves millions of lives has also created weapons that can destroy the whole world. So is science a blessing or a curse?
Science has been a great blessing to humanity. In medicine, vaccines and antibiotics have conquered deadly diseases like smallpox and polio, and modern surgery saves countless lives; the rapid development of COVID-19 vaccines showed its power. In agriculture, improved seeds, fertilisers and irrigation have increased food production and reduced famine. Transport and communication have made the world a global village: we can travel across continents in hours and talk to anyone anywhere instantly. Electricity, computers and the internet have transformed education, business and entertainment. Science also helps us predict weather and earthquakes and prepare for disasters.
However, science can also be a curse when it is misused. Nuclear, chemical and biological weapons can wipe out entire cities. Factories and vehicles have caused air and water pollution, and the burning of fossil fuels has led to climate change, melting our Himalayan glaciers. Modern machines have made people physically inactive, and excessive use of mobile phones and social media has led to addiction, isolation and the spread of false information. Technology has also replaced many jobs and widened the gap between rich and poor.
In fact, science itself is neither good nor bad; it is a tool. A knife can be used by a surgeon to save a life or by a criminal to take one. Whether science becomes a blessing or a curse depends on how humans use it. As Keilis-Borok says, human qualities are more important than science, but "if humanly used, science is their indispensable guardian and caretaker."
In conclusion, science is a great blessing when it is guided by wisdom, ethics and concern for humanity and nature. We must use it for peace, health and sustainable development, not for war and destruction. Then science will truly remain the token of humankind's survival.
Additional Important Questions
1. What did Tolstoy say about writers, and how does the essayist apply it to scientists?
Answer: Tolstoy said that a writer is not merely a person who writes; a writer is a person who cannot live without writing. The essayist says the same is true for scientists: they choose science because they cannot live without it, not for money.
2. What is MAD?
Answer: MAD stands for "Mutually Assured Destruction". During the Cold War, each superpower had enough nuclear weapons to destroy the other, and the other could retaliate within minutes. This threat of total destruction for both sides was the only thin thread preventing nuclear war.
3. How were scientists from opposite sides of the Iron Curtain able to work together?
Answer: Despite their political and cultural differences, they were all scientists. They developed a common language based on respect for hard evidence, ranking by expertise only, and persistent self-criticism. This allowed them to find a solution together.
4. What did the Geneva episode teach the writer?
Answer: It taught him that as a scientist he has people all over the world who think and interact the way he does, so he should never feel lonely abroad. Above all, it taught him that while there is science, there is hope of survival and well-being for all of us.
5. What does the writer say about science and human qualities at the end?
Answer: He says science is not the beginning and the end; human qualities are more important for humankind and for each individual. However, if science is used humanely, it is the indispensable guardian and caretaker of those human qualities.
More Class 11 English Notes
← Previous: What Is Poverty?
Next: Trifles →
All units and chapters: Class 11 English Guide (NEB) – Language Development and Literature