What Is Poverty?
by Jo Goodwin Parker
In this post, you will find complete notes on the essay What Is Poverty? by Jo Goodwin Parker from the Class 11 English (NEB) textbook: an introduction to the author, a summary, the main ideas and writing style, and answers to all the textbook questions, including model definition essays.
About the Author
Jo Goodwin Parker is an unknown writer believed to be from West Virginia in the southern United States. The essay was mailed to George Henderson, a professor at the University of Oklahoma, while he was writing his 1971 book America's Other Children: Public Schools Outside Suburbia. It was signed "Jo Goodwin Parker", and the writer asked that no further identification be given.
Nothing more has ever been discovered about the writer. Whether she was a poor woman describing her own painful life, or a sympathetic writer who adopted her voice, remains a mystery. For this reason the essay is presented without biographical details, which also lets it speak for all poor people.
Introduction to the Essay
"What Is Poverty?" is a powerful extended definition essay written from the point of view of a young mother living in rural poverty. Instead of defining poverty with statistics, she defines it through her own daily experiences: dirt, smell, tiredness, illness, shame and hopelessness. Speaking directly to the reader ("you"), she asks not for pity but for understanding and action. Her vivid, emotional language makes the reader feel the harsh reality of being poor.
Summary
The speaker asks the reader to listen to her "without pity" but "with understanding", and to imagine being in her dirty, worn-out shoes. She then defines poverty through a series of statements, each beginning "Poverty is...".
Poverty is getting up from a dirty, illness-stained mattress and living in a smell that never leaves: of urine, sour milk, rotting food, cheap onions and garbage. The refrigerator is broken, and she cannot even bury the garbage because a shovel costs money.
Poverty is being tired. She has chronic anaemia from poor diet and worms and needs an operation, but she has no money for iron pills, medicine or surgery. She once took a job, leaving her three children with "Granny", but came home to find the baby with flesh stuck to an unchanged diaper and the other children in danger. She earned $22 a week and child care cost $20, so she quit.
Poverty is dirt. She washes dishes in cold water without soap, because soap must be saved for diapers and hot water costs money. Her hands are cracked and red; once she saved for two months for Vaseline, only to find the price had gone up two cents. She looks much older than she is.
Poverty is staying up on cold nights watching the fire in case a spark sets fire to the newspaper on the walls. In summer, flies feed on the baby's tears; insects get into food, noses and eyes. When it rains, diapers will not dry. Her children always have runny noses. Poverty is cooking without food and cleaning without soap.
Poverty is asking for help. She describes circling the welfare office in shame, telling her story again and again to the wrong people, being told to wait, and feeling "the red cloud of shame and the rising cloud of despair".
Poverty is remembering. She left school because of cruel classmates; her mother falsely told the attendance officer she was pregnant so that she could work. She married young and once had a decent life, but her husband lost his job, they lost their possessions, and they had three babies in three years. Unable to afford birth control, she let her marriage end, and her husband left. Now she gets $78 a month for four people, paying $20 in rent and spending the rest on grits, cornmeal, rice, milk and beans.
Poverty is looking into a black future. She fears her sons will turn to stealing, alcohol or drugs and end up in prison, and that her daughter will live a life like hers. Schools and health clinics exist, but her children are sick and malnourished, and the clinic is eight miles away. A neighbour who gives her rides expects to be paid "one way or another" while complaining about government money for "immoral mothers".
"Poverty is an acid that drips on pride until all pride is worn away." Still, even the poor can dream: of money for the right food, medicine, soap and hot water, and of help that does not destroy the last bit of pride. She ends by telling readers that people like her are all around them. She asks them to look at the poor "with an angry heart", anger that will make them help: "The poor are always silent. Can you be silent too?"
Main Ideas of the Essay
- Poverty is not an abstract idea but a daily experience of dirt, smell, hunger, illness and exhaustion.
- Poverty is a vicious cycle: lack of money leads to poor health, lost education and jobs, and a hopeless future.
- The poor lose dignity when they ask for help; welfare systems are slow and humiliating.
- Social prejudice blames the poor instead of understanding them.
- Solutions like schools, clinics and welfare do not reach the poorest people properly.
- The poor need understanding and action, not pity; society must not stay silent.
Before Reading
a. What do you consider poverty to be? Do you have a definitive explanation of it or do you consider it an abstract circumstance?
Answer: Poverty is a condition in which a person or family lacks enough money and resources to meet basic needs such as food, clothing, shelter, health care and education. It can be measured with definite indicators, such as income below the poverty line, but it is also more than numbers. It includes hunger, illness, lack of opportunities, shame and hopelessness. So poverty is both a definite economic condition and a deep human experience that is hard to explain fully in words.
b. Look at the picture. What do you see? Where do you see such people? Who are the poor? Why are they poor? Where do the poor usually live?
Answer: The picture shows poor people living in miserable conditions, in old, dirty clothes, looking tired and helpless. We see such people in slums and squatter settlements in cities, on footpaths, under bridges, and in remote villages.
The poor are people who cannot meet their basic needs: landless farmers, daily-wage labourers, the unemployed, the homeless, beggars, and many marginalised groups. They are poor because of lack of education and skills, unemployment, low wages, landlessness, illness, large families, natural disasters, discrimination and unequal distribution of resources. They usually live in slums, squatter settlements, rural and remote areas, and places with poor roads, water and health services.
Understanding the Text
a. What is poverty according to Parker?
Answer: According to Parker, poverty is not just a lack of money but a whole way of suffering. It is getting up from a dirty mattress and living in a smell that never leaves; being always tired and ill; dirt; staying up on cold nights in fear of fire; cooking without food and cleaning without soap; asking for help with shame; remembering a lost past; and looking into a black future. Above all, "poverty is an acid that drips on pride until all pride is worn away."
b. How is poverty difficult for Parker's children? List some specific examples.
Answer: Poverty makes life very hard for her children:
- They sleep on the floor or in her one bed on a dirty mattress.
- The baby's diaper was left unchanged so long that bits of flesh came off with it.
- Flies and gnats feed on the baby's tears; insects crawl over them while they sleep.
- They always have runny noses because tissues and medicine cost money.
- They suffer from worms, infections and pink-eye, and from malnutrition.
- They have no extra books, pencils, crayons or paper for school.
- They live in danger of fire and are left alone in unsafe situations.
- Their future looks dark: her sons may turn to crime or drugs, and her daughter may live a life like hers.
c. How does Parker try to obtain help, and what problems does she encounter?
Answer: Parker goes to the welfare office to ask for help. She circles the block four or five times out of shame before going in. Everyone is busy, and the first person she speaks to is never the right one. After "spilling the whole shame" of her poverty, she is told she is in the wrong office and must repeat the process elsewhere. She is told to wait, and the explanation is lost in "the red cloud of shame and the rising cloud of despair". In the end she receives only $78 a month for four people. Asking for help costs her pride and dignity.
d. Why are people's opinions and prejudices her greatest obstacles?
Answer: People's opinions and prejudices are her greatest obstacles because they blame the poor instead of understanding them. Comfortable people say, "Anybody can be clean," without knowing that soap and hot water cost money. They believe the poor are lazy or immoral, like her neighbour who complains about government spending on "immoral mothers of illegitimate children" while expecting payment for giving her rides. Children were cruel about her clothes and smell, so she left school. Such attitudes make her feel ashamed, discourage her from asking for help, and prevent society from solving poverty.
e. How does Parker defend her inability to get help? How does she discount the usual solutions society has for poverty (e.g. welfare, education and health clinics)?
Answer: Parker explains that help is hard to get because the system is humiliating and inefficient: she must go from office to office, retelling her story, proving her poverty again and again, and then waiting. The help she finally gets, $78 a month, is barely enough for food.
She shows why the usual solutions do not work for her. Welfare is too small and costs her pride. Schools exist, but her children have no books or supplies and, most of all, no health; they are already damaged by malnutrition before they reach school. Health clinics exist, but they are in town, eight miles away, and she cannot walk sixteen miles with small children, while her neighbour expects payment for a ride. Jobs do not help because child care costs almost as much as she earns. Even health education is useless when she has no money to follow it.
Reference to the Context
a. Explain: "Poverty is looking into a black future."
Answer: With this line, Parker means that poverty takes away all hope for the future. She sees no way out for her children. Her sons will not be accepted by other children and may turn to boys who steal, ending up "behind the bars of their prison instead of behind the bars of my poverty", or they may become addicted to alcohol or drugs. Her daughter, at best, will live a life like hers. Poverty is passed from one generation to the next, so the future looks dark ("black") and hopeless.
b. What does Parker mean by "The poor are always silent"?
Answer: Parker means that poor people usually do not speak out about their suffering. They are too ashamed, too tired, too busy surviving, or too powerless to be heard. They listen politely to doctors and officials and do not protest. Society also ignores them, so their voices are never heard. By asking "Can you be silent too?", she challenges readers not to remain silent but to speak and act on behalf of the poor.
c. What writing strategy does the author use at the beginning of most of the paragraphs? Do you notice a recurring pattern? What is it?
Answer: The author begins most paragraphs with the phrase "Poverty is...": "Poverty is getting up every morning...", "Poverty is being tired", "Poverty is dirt", "Poverty is asking for help", "Poverty is remembering", "Poverty is looking into a black future". This is the strategy of repetition (anaphora) used to build an extended definition. Each paragraph defines poverty from a new angle and supports it with concrete examples. The recurring pattern gives the essay unity, rhythm and emotional force.
d. How does Parker develop each paragraph? What details make each paragraph memorable?
Answer: Parker develops each paragraph by starting with a short definition ("Poverty is...") and then supporting it with specific, concrete examples from her own life. She uses vivid sensory details (smell, sight, touch), facts and figures, and short, direct sentences.
Memorable details include: the smell of urine, sour milk and long-cooked onions; the shovel she cannot afford; the baby's flesh coming off with the dried diaper; saving for two months for Vaseline, only to find the price had risen by two cents; flies eating the baby's tears; the newspaper on the walls that could catch fire; circling the welfare office in shame; and the $78 a month for four people. These images make poverty real and unforgettable.
e. In the final paragraph, how does the author use questions to involve the reader in the issue of poverty?
Answer: In the final paragraph, Parker reminds readers that people like her are "all around you" and asks them to look at the poor "with an angry heart". She ends with the question "The poor are always silent. Can you be silent too?" This rhetorical question directly challenges the reader. It makes the reader feel personally responsible and asks them to choose between staying silent and speaking out. Throughout the essay she also asks questions like "Have you ever had to ask for help...?" and "but for year after year after year?" to make readers imagine themselves in her place.
Reference Beyond the Text
a. Define a social problem (homelessness, unemployment, racism) imitating Parker's style.
Answer: Here is a definition of unemployment in Parker's style:
What Is Unemployment?
You ask me what unemployment is? Listen to me. Do not pity me. Pity does not pay the rent. Just listen.
Unemployment is waking up with nowhere to go. My certificates lie in a plastic folder, wrapped carefully so the rain does not spoil them. I have a Bachelor's degree. I have read every word of every job advertisement in the newspaper. I have applied to forty offices. Forty times I have heard, "We will call you." No one calls.
Unemployment is shame. It is lowering my eyes when my father comes home tired from carrying loads, knowing he paid for my education by selling his land. It is avoiding relatives at weddings because they ask, "What are you doing these days?" It is pretending to be busy.
Unemployment is counting coins. It is walking to save bus fare and skipping lunch to save money for photocopies of my certificates.
Unemployment is a passport. It is standing in a long queue outside the manpower office, where everyone has the same dream: a job in the desert heat, far from home. It is saying goodbye to my mother at the airport, knowing I may come back in a box like my neighbour's son.
I have told you this so that you know. We are not lazy. We are not useless. There are thousands like me in every town. Do not look away. Can you stay silent too?
b. Using adjectives to highlight the futility of the situation, write a short definition essay on "Growing up in Poverty".
Growing up in Poverty
Growing up in poverty means growing up hungry, tired and ashamed. It is a long, grey, hopeless childhood in which dreams are too expensive to keep.
Growing up in poverty is waking up in a cold, damp, leaking room, sharing one thin, torn blanket with three brothers and sisters. It is walking to school on bare, cracked feet, carrying a borrowed, tattered book in a plastic bag. It is sitting at the back of the class in a faded, oversized uniform, hoping no one notices the patched shirt.
Growing up in poverty is a hungry, aching stomach that makes it impossible to understand the teacher's difficult, distant words. It is a sick, feverish body with no money for medicine. It is a weary, worried mother and an absent father working in a far, foreign country.
Growing up in poverty is leaving school too early to earn a few rupees in a dusty, dangerous brick kiln or a noisy, crowded restaurant. It is watching richer, luckier children go to college while your own future looks dark, narrow and closed.
Growing up in poverty is being small, silent and invisible. It is a cycle that is cruel, endless and unfair, and it will continue until society decides to break it.
Additional Important Questions
1. Why does Parker ask the reader to listen "without pity"?
Answer: She does not want pity because pity does not change her situation and only makes her feel smaller. She wants readers to listen with understanding, put themselves in her shoes, and feel an anger that will lead them to help.
2. Why did Parker quit her job?
Answer: She earned $22 a week, but good child care for three children cost $20 a week. When she left the children with "Granny", they were neglected and in danger. So working did not make sense, and she quit.
3. Why did Parker's marriage end?
Answer: After her husband lost his job, they lost everything and had three babies in three years. Unable to afford birth control and unwilling to bring more children into such dirt, she "destroyed" the marriage, and her husband left. She hopes he has escaped the poverty.
4. What does Parker dream of?
Answer: She dreams of money for the right food, worm medicine, iron pills, toothbrushes, hand cream, tools to repair the house, soap and hot water. She also dreams of a welfare system that helps quickly and respectfully, where she needs to tell her story to only one person.
5. Explain: "Poverty is an acid that drips on pride until all pride is worn away."
Answer: This metaphor compares poverty to acid that slowly eats away at something. Day after day, poverty and the humiliation of asking for help destroy a person's self-respect and dignity, until nothing of their pride is left.
More Class 11 English Notes
← Previous: What I Require from Life
Next: Scientific Research Is a Token of Humankind's Survival →
All units and chapters: Class 11 English Guide (NEB) – Language Development and Literature